News - Soap Buzz

109 November 29th, 2012 Soap Opera Digest Names: GH – Best Show, Y&R Most Disappointing Show, OLTL – Best Good-Bye!

We are now at that time in the calendar year when all of the major entertainment publications begins to roll-out their Best & Worst Of 2012, something we always look forward to and to see who got top honors!

In soapland, it is Soap Opera Digest that for decades has honored the achievements or lack of achievements in the soap genre for the year.  And while, On-Air On-Soaps does not release it’s official Best and Worst List till the final week of December leading into New Year’s Eve, here were Soap Opera Digest picks in a few of the major categories! (To see them all, run don’t walk to your newsstands and pick up the latest issue on sale now!)

SOD names General Hospital as the Best Show Of 2012 citing, “GH consistently charmed churned out episodes rich with humor, heart, surprise after surprise, that checked off items on viewers wish list one by one!”

On the flip side SOD named The Young and the Restless, Most Disappointing Show of 2012 commenting,  “Stories predicated on the trouble-making of an unhinged psycho are tried-and-true soap fare, but you’d think Y&R would have learned a lesson from 2011. We got more Patty (in a cartoonish reprisal), Daisy screeching that she just wanted to be loved and Ricky suddenly unspooling into a homicidal maniac, with his own dad, Paul, being charged with his death!”

One Life to Live was given the honor of Best Goodbye for it’s send0ff, with SOD reminding us all, “The build to the final of episodes was enriched by fan-fave returns as OLTL’s writer delicately interwove heartfelt themes of love and family incorporating the entire cast, punctuated by reunions, new beginnings, satisfying resolutions and a stunning surprise. As much as we hated to say farewell, it was a hankie-worthy joy to see it go out on top.”

Ok soapers, do you agree with SOD’s picks for Best Show, Most Disappointing Show, Best Good-Bye?  Let us know your thoughts!

 

Tags: , , , ,

  1. Dinah says:

    I so disagree about GH being the best Show

    Reply

    Evan replied

    Really? Surprise after surprise? The use of the older characters and past history to make great story lines for today? The use of EVERYBODY in the cast, not just Sonny, Carly, Sam, etc.? The fact that everybody has a story going on right now and its all very diverse? The fact that the story lines aren’t dragging and are more fast-paced and suspenseful?

    Reply

    Rodd replied

    I totally agree with you Evan.

    susan M. replied

    I agree with Evan also!!!!! I agree the story lines aren’t dragging .. Like years ago you could tune in months later & you didn’t miss much.. GH ie definetely
    keeping my attention Mon.-Fri. Can’t wait to see what happens next….

    The_HugoBoss replied

    2nd that! I said the same thing a week ago!

    Jules replied

    Well I agree with you Dinah. It draws me in less today than when Guza was in charge….and that’s saying A LOT.

    A. LOT.

    Reply

    dg replied

    GH is the most improved but def not the best show. Despite its derailment this year I still say YR is the best show. They have the most consistent , well drawn characters and usually the stories have much more substance.
    Cartini have turned GH into a sensational cartoon, much like they did OLTL. Their silly stories get ratings, but for those of us who want substance there is always Y&R.

    Reply

    susan M. replied

    Well I enjoy GH each day and have no complaints about the story line. And I also liked OLTL a lot & still miss it. Again I can’t wait to watch GH each day….I find it interesting and suspenseful…I have alway’s watched this soap & I will stay with GH..

    The_HugoBoss replied

    Substance? Like Nick choosing Phyllis? Then Sharon? Then Phyllis again? Then Sharon again? Then back to Phyllis? Then his dad marrying Sharon. After his brother dated her. Ummm….should we mention Angeline? lol.
    Granted, I do watch Y&R, and like some of the stories that don’t drag out for two years, but saying GH has no substance when you have stories a out surrogatcy, and events to raise awareness for AIDS research, family dealing with the death of the father/grandfather/gg……saying that there’s NO substance may be pushing it a bit. lol.

    Phil replied

    Y&R is by far the most overrated soap on TV…GH deserves top nods. I say that there is much substance in both shows, but GH executes it with far more emotion and ease!

  2. Ronphy says:

    Hi Michael for me YR miss some
    Passion and some happyness they have the most incredible couple with Ronan and Phyllis and they brake it Phonan have so much chemistry we feel the connection look real yes its desapointed and hope they give us romance

    Reply

  3. Ryan says:

    I would agree with most, except, I would name Days as the worst. While it has one good storyline, the show overall, is incredibly week. Y&R has not yet got moving again at full speed but they have made huge changes behind the scenes to address its weaknesses. The stories are slow at this point but at least the nightmare does appear to be over. The changes at Days have done nothing to improve the overall show.

    Reply

    Mandy replied

    The nightmare for Y&R does not appear to be over. Quite the contrary. Only the same few are on every day. Unlike GH who uses EVERYBODY!

    Reply

  4. SAM MOON says:

    B&B is the best

    Reply

    debra meadows replied

    are you kidding……this whole year it has been steffy always there to interfear with hope and liam, hope and liam get back together, than steffy again breaking them up….and of course brooke and ridge, we had to watch all that crap in italy, just for them to remarry, go on a honeymoon, then ridge leaves. they did not stay true to the characters…,im going to miss stephanie…

    Reply

  5. Annie says:

    Completely agree about Y&R. I had watched the show since the 70′s, but started to not enjoy it as much when it became clear that Adam would never pay for his crimes and they killed Colleen so that idiot Victor could live, and finally stopped altogether with the Sharon/Victor fiasco. I only read the recaps now and am about to quit on that also, they have just destroyed that show. I followed Eileen Davidson over to Days and love it, so at least I still have a soap to follow, but I miss the old Y&R.

    Reply

    Monica replied

    So agree about how they killed off Colleen! It was also heartbreaking the way they killed off Brad too. Devastating!

    Reply

    west vorgina fan replied

    have faith–I only read recaps for the worst of the mob years on gh but watch it on youtube every night now

  6. LINDA says:

    I Agree GH has Been AWESOME and has put out very good Soap having to do with Love ,Family and every thing else that makes for a good show
    Y&R had been SO BAD FOR SO LONG and it keeps being that way the Stories are so Lame we the fans can tell where the story line will go b4 it even gets there and they use the same people on the show over and over this is Y&R not the NEWMAN HOUR. there are OTHER Families on the show we fans want to see on the show Y&R need Balance and good Story telling they still do not have that
    OLTL Gave a Great sent off and it had the fans wanting More I hope one day we will see OLTL back on air

    Reply

    susan M. replied

    OLTL send off made me want more stories..It left a lot of those stories up in the air
    foe me…The stories weren’t an ending but a beginning to new stories for OLTL..

    Reply

  7. Tracy says:

    They nailed OLTL’s goodbye. It was poignant and downright perfect. GH has been getting better and better. Way to go RC & FV!

    Reply

    D Hewitt replied

    I agree with you, Tracy. How about that weird plot twist right now where Alcazar and Tomas (OLTL) are the same person? I don’t recall that EVER happening on a Soap, Which is a surprise when you think about how many actors have moved from show to show,

    Don H

    Reply

    Rodd replied

    Totally agree with you, Tracy.

    Reply

    susan M. replied

    I agree with Tracy …OLTL’s goodbye was great but it left me wanting more !!!

  8. Jessy says:

    Hi Michael im a Big fan Of you and Of YR
    Since 30 years i was anxious to see what the writer Will do and im little bit desapointed too they CAN explore new things like Ronan and Phyllis this couple bring something new to this show and we all love it they become my favorite and love to see more Of shadam they bring passion too the fan need that just heard that Jeff branson is leaving what a Big lost for this show
    Thank you to read me
    Jessy xx

    Reply

  9. Jennifer says:

    SOAP OPERA DIGEST IS RIGHT ABOUT THE YOUNG AND THE RESTLESS IT IS THE MOST DISAPPOINTED SHOW OF 2012 BECAUSE THEY HAVE PHYLLIS HUSBAND MESS WITH PHYLLIS LITTLE SISTER WHO IS FAMILY I AM NOT INTEREST IN WATCHING THAT IT IS NASTY THEY DON’T HAVE CHEMISTRY AT ALL.

    Reply

  10. Lisa says:

    I agree 100%

    Reply

  11. Toni says:

    I think Y&R should get Most Improved Show! I really don’t think it was the most disappointing show before, either.

    Reply

  12. Manon says:

    Hi ! Michael
    Love your writing !
    Im a Big fan too Of YR and yes the show is Boring sorry but true
    Like the other people who write here i see a major couple in Phonan they have it their chemistry is Phenominal they deserve a major love story not Navery JB and MS are great together the BEST in longtime love to see more Billy and Victoria YR miss what is the most important for people LOVE go take Back JB and write them something that would blow in our face something beautiful and magic like Never before sure YR Will regain more audience
    Thank you !
    ManonR

    Reply

    ethel replied

    well we are not going to get anything now from phyllis & ronan because jeff branson is leaving the show again…………

    Reply

  13. Sal Piscioneri says:

    Agree 100%….

    Reply

  14. Jules says:

    GH best show? PU-LEEZE. ConnieKate? A tired baby switch storyline? Robin’s horribly conceived and executed funeral? Lack of storyline for so many? More useless newbies than I can keep track of? This GH worship is working my last nerve. Haven’t watched in months and you couldn’t pay me to.

    I think for the 2 weeks it aired this year, OLTL was probably the Best Soap. Heartfelt, entertaining, engaging, surprising, traditional but still creative, beautiful.

    B&B focused way, waaaay, WAAAAAAAY too heavily on 3 obnoxious characters.
    YR was a hot mess I stopped following that one too.

    And my beloved DAYS had its ups (Alzheimer’s story, Kristen’s return, EJ/Sami, Will’s coming out, Abby’s lie, Lexie’s passing) and downs (Nicole’s obsession with Daniel, Gabi’s pregnancy, Ian’s manipulations, Alamania *shudders*, Rafe/Carrie, Jack “dying” again) so it rightly goes somewhere in between.

    Reply

    Matt replied

    You haven’t watched in months but you thunk GH is the worst? Not a fair opinion.

    Reply

    Jules replied

    So says you. I’ll also never put crocs on my feet but I still maintain they are one of the ugliest pairs of shoes ever created.

    Just because I refuse to watch does not mean I can’t have an opinion. I know enough without having to spend a single solitary second of my day watching.

    Matt replied

    This is why I don’t normally make comments. People who don’t watch the show who are sure that it sucks should keep their uneducated opinions to themselves. And liking the work of a writer doesn’t make me a butt kisser.

    Jules replied

    “Uneducated” is an interesting choice of word to associate with watching a daytime soap opera. Just saying…..

    And I don’t believe I ever said “butt kisser”.

    Hey, you have your opinion of the show, for which you are entitled to. As am I. I left my opinion. It was your choice to comment on it.

    dg replied

    I agree Jules. All of the Cartini butt kisser are way off base. There is so much wrong with GH still. Like you mentioned, Kate/Connie, the lame Jasam baby switch, the Krstina Trey newbie casting and lackluster romance, the ridiculous latex masquerade with Faison pretending to be Duke, the lack luster Luke and Anna Romance, Britt, Sabrina, Patrick, Elli Spinelli and that name game nerd romance.
    I could go on. AJ’s return is about the only story that doesnt bastardize history and has the potential to be a multilayered, intelligent engaging tale. The rest of it is a saturday morning cartoon, lol.

    Reply

    susan M. replied

    I a enjoying GH.. And I am a die-hard fan of OLTL !!!!! And I like GH too and like the
    storylines .Much better from years ago. They are definetely on the right track now…
    That’s my opinion….

    Reply

  15. Mark Schreier says:

    I’m really worried about Y & R. Nobody seems to realize what Sony did by putting JFP in charge. I don’t have any personal feelings about her one way or the other, but I know her track record and am starting to see Y & R get even more disappointing under her leadership. The Bells deserve such a better legacy for their work than what her leadership will provide. It’s just sad. From changing a sweet boy Kyle into a skirt-chasing young adult who doesn’t even fit in with the Abbott family (speech patterns and all) is just the beginning of the show’s issues…. having Daisy disappear with her “mother”, Danny apparently moving with Lucy to Chicago (I must have missed that episode), Genevieve’s character becoming totally unredeamable with such a fine actress, all of the nepatism at the two main companies, the unresolved ending of Phyllis’ 20-year-old storyline… this is all just the beginning of what I’m afraid will lead to a severe loss of viewership. I hope I’m wrong. But for some reason, soap leaders only turn to insiders for help with solving issues instead of realizing there are plenty of educated viewers who have invested years in following a show who just may have some good FRESH ideas to breathe new life into them. The game of Exec. Prod. roulette (except for GH) has proven to be the demise of almost every soap. When will someone at Sony see the light? I just don’t get it. I know all I am is a viewer who created and wrote a college soap with more engaging characters than Y & R has now ….with original storylines (not recycled ones) that later turned up on GL and AMC 10 years later.. but it’s sad. The Bell family is who I feel the saddest for… they deserve so much better. Plus the viewers, like myself, who have watched this show since the beginning in 1973. Everyone, especially the actors, deserve so much better. But here we go again — recycled storylines of drug addiction, family business squabbles, Phyllis’ continual self-destructive behavior (apparently soon to be with Kyle, no less), it’s all just old recycled stuff that will lead to boring shows, loss of respect for long-time chacters, and loss of viewership. Like I said at the beginning, nobody seems to worry about JFP’s leadership except me.

    Reply

    Troy Turner replied

    You have a right to your opinion, and I can’t/won’t dispute it since I’m not a regular viewer of YR, but don’t insult our intelligence trying to get yourself over. It’s sickening

    Reply

    dg replied

    From what many insiders have said JFP doesnt have autonomy at YR. Sony is ruling the show with an iron fist. She has to clear all her major decisions with them. So far Josh Griffith’s writing is going well in my opinion. None of the major vets have been killed off her backburnered so things are so far so good. I enjoy the show alot more. YR is bouncing back and they were in no where near the bad shape that plagued GH. And yes I was very worried when I heard JFP was coming to YR.
    But again she is a figure head. The real power belongs to Sony.

    Reply

    Mark Schreier replied

    I hope so … the show has so much potential such so much history and longtime actors/characters….we’ll see what happens!

  16. aria says:

    well, Dinah, to bad, because Gh was the best show, it delivered all all fronts, and it had buzz all year round, cant say the same for the other shows.

    Reply

    Rodd replied

    So true, Aria.

    Reply

  17. gslam says:

    I so AGREE with all three decisions! Perfect!

    Reply

  18. Madison says:

    I so agree with GH being the best show & only b/c of them adding the OLTL characters on. I so miss OLTL!!

    Reply

    Bruce replied

    Couldn’t have said it better myself!!

    Reply

    susan M. replied

    DITTO!!!

    Reply

  19. Madison says:

    Oh & Sam of course I just wish they would find a way to bring Jason back..

    Reply

  20. Debbie Hamilton says:

    Yes GH is the best! No soap keeps me as rivited as General Hospital. The intermingling of OLTL actors with GH was superp and only brought more enjoyment to the program.
    May the show last another 50 years. The writers deserve an award for showing the powers that be they know what they’re doing! Keep it up guys :)

    Reply

    Rodd replied

    Hear! Hear!

    Reply

    susan M. replied

    I agree with Debbie 100%…………..

    Reply

  21. John says:

    GH is the best show on daytime right now !!!

    Reply

    susan M. replied

    I agree…..

    Reply

  22. debikra says:

    If Y&R is so disapointing, why are they number 1??
    GH has breathed life back into the show. I LOVE what the writers have done I congragulate them, and imo anyone who doesn’t enjoy GH shouldn’t be watching it.

    Reply

    aria replied

    because people watch crap, duh, thats why Y&R is #1 and thats why jersey shore was mtv highest rated show.

    Reply

    debikra replied

    duh?? With a vocabulary like that its easier to understand your way of thinking.

    Jersey Shore?? Really?? hahahahahaha

    Aria replied

    You wanna now talk about ” vocabulary ” debrika??? Hahahahahaha. Okay!

    Mary SF replied

    I would hardly compare y&r to the jersey shore, but everyone is entitled to their opinion.

    dg replied

    YR is number one because they never lost as much of their core audience as GH and the ABC soaps did over the last ten yrs. YR continues to average near 5 million viewers. Over the last few yrs GH struggle for 2 million.
    And since 2000 ABC and Frons destroyed GH’s core families and gutted the show, handing it over to Sonny. They have never recovered from those mistakes fully. Ive been watching since 1969 and despite all of Cartini’s sensational, cartoonish stories the show hasnt been the same for me.
    The only real story that truly interests me is the return of AJ because it was returned the Qs to the front burner. But I fear that wont last long.

    Reply

    ethel replied

    i have been watching gh since the beginning & right now this is the best i have seen gh in the last 8 to 10 years & the new regime has done an excellent job in getting gh back to being an enjoyable soap – it is perfect no but is is much better than it was……….

    susan M. replied

    I watch GH everday. It’s habit forming. And you want to watch it everyday…

    Reply

    susan M. replied

    What do you mean cartoonish stories? I don’t understand….

  23. Chris says:

    I have not read the issue, but sadly, I agree with their choice of Y&R as disappointing show. IT seems everyone but Maria Bell was on the same page about this once stellar drama. She was the most in denial about how bad it gotten. Never was it more evident than when she took to Facebook after her firing to defend her poor choices.

    As far as the new regime goes, six weeks into their run, I’m 50/50 with them. I think the acting is much better with JFP there. Actors formerly sleep walking through their scenes have come alive again. Show looks more polished at least visually. I’m not a fan of how she has all but abandoned the old Y&R music and replaced it with what sounds like low end production music that adds little if nothing to scenes. I feel a little like I’m watching LML’s Y&R all over again…at least from a producing standpoint. Also I really wish the show would go back to the style of directing we saw in last Friday’s 2002 encore episode. I miss the tighter shots on the actors faces Y&R was know for. Everything is so wide. No intimacy what-so-ever. Even the best prime-time dramas still get the camera in tight on the actors faces. The constant wide shots make the soap viewing experience feel less intimate. Also please put the furniture back the way it was in Katherine’s house!! There was a scene yesterday with Jill, Chole and Lauren that merely highlighted the flaws in this layout. You could only see the back of Lauren’s head and her profile while she sat on the sofa with Chloe. What advantage is there in only seeing the back of your actors heads when they speak? It was poorly done and not an on par with a show that has been decorated with as many directing Emmy’s as Y&R has.

    From a writing stand-point I do like the Phyllis storyline. I think having everyone turn on her, especially Nick, is compelling drama. The romance between Nick and Avery has also been pleasant to watch and made this former pointless character interesting. Avery in the kitchen is more interesting than Avery in the courtroom. Maybe I’m just tired of court related stories on this show as we over-dosed on them during the MAB years. The early indications that Kevin could be returning to his older self is also exciting. Greg Rikkart’s character had become so bland I could barely muster the interest to watch him on screen anymore. Unhinged Kevin is way more interesting that well to do Kevin. Let’s not forget this guy lit himself on fire to avoid going to jail. A do-gooder he is not. What I’m not digging is the speed at which some of these tales are being told. I think its such a mistake for soaps, who are on 5 days a week, 52 weeks a year, to speed through stories the way prime-time does. Soaps have to produce 15 times the amount of material than their counterparts. I wish they would take their time to develop the characters and situations more realistically. Jack’s addition storyline is a good example of that. He’s become a pill addict almost over-night and peaked the curiosity and concern of too many people to quickly. I always feel like the network heads who force this fast pace model on their writers and show runners is like a person losing at a poker table who no longer is making the most sensible choices. GIve the audience credit that we still want to see a story unfold. Hit those emotional beats that are so crucial as part of the bigger picture. Streamline stories so that they intersect each other instead of standing in their own isolated vortex. It was especially a problem during the Maria years where most stories didn’t spawn off other compelling ones. I fear the new regime structures things similarly, as we have already seen, with that plot driven Victoria kidnapping mess. A story that came out of nowhere and felt like something Maria herself conjured up. Same for the cyber-stalking story. None of the players involved (Fen, Summer, Jamie) are developed enough as characters that they should be driving story. The former 2 grew up overnight and the latter just started on the show. All three have little connection to the audience because they have never been developed. It’s “C” characters driving story. How is that supposed to get ratings up? The Sharon story is also somewhat disappointing. Sharon Case’s character was picked away at slowly over the years to the shell she is today. I wish the show would have taken us on a more intimate journey as Sharon found herself. Instead the writers blew their wad too quickly by having her burn the ranch down and discover over a few sessions that she’s bi-polar. What’s missing in this necessary rebuild of the once dynamic Sharon is her journey! The discovery of who she was and what she became. People go to therapy for years to reverse behavior but Sharon figured it all out in just a months time. Again how is that supposed to compel viewers to watch and care? An astute viewer recently pointed out that JFP and JG’s Y&R is like MAB’s Y&R on steroids. Not a good review this early on. I’m still hoping for the best but early indications have started to squander my hopes for better change.

    Reply

    Mary SF replied

    You made some excellent observations Chris. The key to successful soap opera writing is all in the timing. If you rush a story line viewers are left not feeling emotionally connected to it like love stories that happen over night. On the other hand go too slow and it will drive viewers crazy waiting for the pay off. I admit Y&R has lost its rhythm- story lines for the last while have either been too fast or too slow, but times have changed from the seventies when this show was conceived. Back then everyone had the luxury of time. No one was trying to watch on the go or through recaps. There were only three networks so no one was breathing down any EP’s neck desperately trying to cling to ever shrinking audience. I think even if Bill Bell Sr. was still alive and writing this soap it would be a challenge given the reality of today’s television landscape. But I am hoping this soap will find its groove again, because nothing is as entertaining as soap that has timing down right.

    Reply

    Troy Turner replied

    Don’t listen to Chris-he’s just upset because he can’t run down GH anymore to promote his anti-soap agenda

    Chris replied

    Thanks Mary for your feedback! I agree with your points as well. There is definitely no rhythm to Y&R anymore. Just a series of stories that don’t always connect to the bigger picture. I’m not hating Y&R as I did when MAB wrote it but I’m just ok with it right now.

    Troy you have me mistaken for another Chris. I don’t watch GH. Keep it classy dude!

    Troy Turner replied

    If you are indeed another Chris-then I stand corrected

    Reply

  24. Mandy says:

    Y&R sucks because it is still the Newman Hour. Hate it! When will it become Y&R again?

    Reply

  25. moshane58 says:

    AMC will always be my favorite but glad to see ABC soaps are the best.You’d think ABC would get the hint and Neilsen.

    Reply

    dg replied

    I completely disagree. The ABC soaps were the best a decade to 15 yrs ago. Since 2000 the ABC soaps hit rock bottom. Until recently YR and BB were always the best quality the highest rated.
    Frons, Phelps, ABC and Cartini decimated their soap line up. Cartini turned agnes nixon’s groundbreaking, socially relevant One Life into a ridiculous campy cartoon. And despite YR’s recent derailment they continue to crush GH in ratings. They still range around 5 million viewers. GH is still under 3.

    Reply

    susan M. replied

    I disagree…

    susan M. replied

    OLTL will alway’s be my favorite soap of all time…Never watched the soaps on those other channels..I watched the Soaps on ABC with my mom so many years ago & still am…

    moshane58 replied

    You know I never watch Y&R but I still wouldn’t condemn it.Want all soaps to suceed.to amny have been cancelled already.now GH is building a new audiences since new people have taken over and glad for it.Glad for your show.So just be glad for all of them instead of condemning them.remember your stuck with the one who help bring down Gh’s ratings.Good Luck on that one.Hopefully Y&R fans will stick by it no matter what.There are alot of ABC soap fans who do watch all of them.Its not like we are all stuck on one network.,We are just fighting Anne Sweeney who wants all soaps gone.So its nothing personnal against any soaps its just the idiot at ABC who thinks talk,new and cooking is all everyone wants now.

  26. Jeff says:

    General Hospital is by far the best soap!!!

    Reply

    dg replied

    Yeah right with latex masks, split personality bimbos, an LSD induced psychic and a younger generation full of talentless performers like Chad Duell, ( Michael) Lindsey Morgan( Kristina), Eric Valdez ( Trey), Kris Alderson ( Star), Kelly Sullivan ( Kate) etc.
    Ive watched GH since 1969. Cartini should write mindless Steven Sagal movies or saturday morning Cartoons. They wouldnt know intelligent, well crafted serialized drama if it bit them in their collected as+ses. Lol.

    Reply

    CTwildheart replied

    I suppose you preferred the Guza era? Mob, mob and more mob?

    susan M. replied

    I agree with Jeff !!!!!!!!

    Reply

  27. Lew S says:

    I would say GH and BB for best. Y&R is trying to reestablish ittself and Days for Chandler Massey and Eileen Davidson.

    Reply

    dg replied

    Its too bad that a once venerable soap like Days has to pander to the gay rights political agenda to be compelling. The rest of that show is a waste of air time. Poor Mac Carey and Francis Reid are no doubt turning over in their graves.

    Reply

  28. JustSaying says:

    I’d say BB is the most disappointing show. Too many Brooke/Ridge storylines. Not enough of the underdog winning the day. Got tired of Hope. Just about every relationship involves different members of the same families. Almost too many cast members with not enough direction or motivation. This show would be fine if it was a one hour show.

    At least YR uses different cast members from time to time. As bad as the writing was, there was some variety.

    Reply

  29. Susan M. says:

    I am looking for opinions on the Steve Harvey Show.. I watched it last wk. when GH wasn’t on which was Thurs & Fri.(Thanksgiving). I watched it all of 10 mins. and I had enough . I found the topics to be silly Etc….. I like him on Family Fued Game Show…Not crazy about his talk show….I will pass on this one….. And loving GH more & more!!!!! Tomas isn’t Tomas but Alkazar….Hope Blair doesn’t marry him.. Blair ,Skye,& Todd got at Tea’s house in the nick of time to tell Blair the truth about him….

    Reply

  30. Mary SF says:

    I have been watching soaps for about 40 years so I seen the good bad and ugly of most daytime serials. The one thing I know is there is no way to please everyone. If they write for one character someone will complain that they are not writing for a different character. If they change the sets, someone will complain the old sets were better. If they don’t change anything, someone will complain nothing changes. But complaining about them is part of the fun of watching of them.

    I don’t know any other genre in television that can hold the attention of its audience even at its worse more than a daytime drama. Y&R had a weak year but most of us who love the show watched it, and suffered along with it. B&B got stuck in the Bermuda triangle of love triangles this year, but those who love the show watched it. Days was all over the map, like living under of cloud of darkness, but with the occasional sunny break to remind you why you watch the show in the first place. As for GH, their fans endured through many a lean year to finally be rewarded with some good old fashion story telling.

    We all love these shows or we wouldn’t be watching them. We want them to continue so we get mad when we know they can do better. We complain because we care. In the end this genre is rare in television and getting rarer and I’m just glad these four soaps are still on the air, because when they go that is it. The daytime drama as we have known it will be gone. Maybe a newer a approach of the continuing drama will emerge out of the ashes, maybe it will never be seen again. But until it happens I will watch, the boring, the dull, the great and the super spectacular because even at worst most daytime dramas are still more entertaining than some nighttime stuff-

    Reply

    Jules replied

    A lovely post Mary! Beautiful words, even if I couldn’t live by them.

    Reply

    Rodd replied

    That’s so true, Mary, for a lot of us long-time, die-hard soap fans; thick or thin, good or bad, we will continue to watch and hope things will improve ~ cheer when they do and gripe when they don’t. When I die, I’m sure they’ll have to tear the remote control out of my hand and turn off GH.

    Reply

    Mary SF replied

    A die-hard soap fan is like a sports fan following their favorite team. They root for them even if they are losing, they root for them even if they don’t make the finals. They will complain on sports radio about the players, coaches and tell everyone who will listen what they would do if they were in charge, but come game time- they are in the stands or watching the television. Why? Loyalty and loyalty used to be the back bone of daytime drama. You watched because it was your soap.

    dg replied

    Great insightful post. But I have to say that over the last yr or so Ive been turning to cable for their serials and I am far more impressed and satisfied. Shows like BoardWalk Empire, Homeland and Game of Thrones are all serials but they are so much more compelling and intelligent.
    Ive watched daytime serials since 1969 and theyve seen better days. Though I treasured the legacy I find myself out growing the camp and silly plots. Like you said I complain about the genre because I want it to do better.

    Reply

    Mary SF replied

    It is easier for nighttime dramas because they are only writing one show per week for so many weeks, while a soap is almost everyday, all year long, for years upon years. Nighttime shows such as one you mentioned will eventually end, while soaps go on for decades. Nothing wrong with those shows you mentioned but it is a bit unfair to compare them to daytime because is a different format.

    Part of the problem is that we are now living in a world that is motivated by trends, whether it be vampires, s&m novels or the latest craze on Y Tube. The PTB know this and they pressure shows to come up with gimmicks to get the buzz going, but once that has aired, those viewers are gone. Back in the sixties a show would never release what day a beloved character was going to die, you would have to watch every day just in case that was the day it was going to happen. Back then, couples falling in love, their first kiss, their first lovemaking, their marriage, their break and divorce used to take a year or more to play out, nowadays those things can happen in a month on some soaps, because no one has the time and patience to wait for the pay off. It is a different time, and I’m afraid the daytime drama format that flourish in the sixties and seventies is dying out for that reason.

    ethel replied

    excellent post mary! i have been watching soaps for almost 50 years & i could not have said it better myself …………..

    Reply

    k/kay replied

    Oh for the days when you could have a cup of coffee like good old Nancy on ATWT and make it riveting!

  31. Mary Fergen says:

    I absolutely agree with these three choices! GH has been so entertaining, and Y&R has been so dull and boring for quite a while. OLTL did have the best goodbye, but I so wish it hadn’t been cancelled. I still miss OLTL and AMC more than I can say.

    Reply

  32. James says:

    I agree with GH as best show. B&B could’ve been a contender if they didn’t focus on the same three characters ALL YEAR LONG!!!! Y&R was boring and DAYS just can’t seem to get its footing back after the reboot. Before the reboot it had some potential.

    Reply

  33. shar says:

    Absolutely agree that GH is best and OLTL had the best send-off! Kudos to Ron Carlivati and Frank Valentini for both! GH keeps getting better and better. Love it!

    Reply

  34. Nancy says:

    GH is the best show and Y&R has sunk to an all time low. It is now the most boring of all the shows. Funny GH had that category until Frank and Ron came along. Now Y&R has the worst producer and writers of all the shows and eventually the public will see it. JFP from General Hospital fame is seriously terrible and soon the loyal Y&R fans will see what I am talking about. Now there is not a day that goes by that I can hardly wait to see what happens on GH. Best show I have ever seen.

    Reply

  35. heidi says:

    Totally agree with their best soap! GH has always been my fave and most of the time the best overall! Way to go GH!!! Kow if ABC will just keep it on for another 50…

    Reply

  36. Saundra says:

    I agree with the opinion Y&R was very disappointing this year. They have destroyed core characters and couples and continue to bury them (Sharon, Phick). They brought old stories up for B/s reasons. They have not taken advantage of good actors /families like the Winters. And it seems to be getting worst. The blood bath and hate thrown on characters are insulting to the fans. Where are the families that fight yet stay together because they are family versus making pious judgements on loved ones. Abbotts, Chancelors, Newmans , Winters, Baldwins. where are the friends ? And the new writers have biasely invested in and lifted up less prominent characters like Avery to top billing. Saint like characters are just as stupid as the crazy Patty/Ricky/Daisy/Sharon of the past year. Ratings have dropped and long term fans are dropping like flies . If Sony, CBS and the writers don’t wake up soon and stop smelling themselves next year they may not be around to talk about.

    Reply

  37. Peaches says:

    I agree that Y&R has gone down even with the new writers. Every where you look, television is talking against and trying to stop cyberbulling, but Y&R entertains cyberbulling.

    Kyle is the worst actor the Y&R has. His acting is so fake.
    Why is Chelsea still in Y&R and with Adam. It is not a strong story plot. Im tired of looking at them in that dark dull living room.

    I have gotten to the point that I tape Y&R because it is not interesting anymore, but there are some people I still like to see. Since I tape it, I skip the scenes that i do not want to see like: Lily, Neil, Devon, Ester, Chelsea’s mother and father, and Cane roles are very boring. They have no interesting plot. Their role always be a sentence or two and go to the next take. I always skip them.

    Now Victoria is getting ready to leave Billy because Nick left Phyllis. What a weak storyline.

    Kevins mother Gloria, she looks scary.

    I really thought the new writer(s) was going to makeY&R a more interesting show, but it has gotten duller. I skip more of the show than what I look at.

    Y&R NEEDS HELP!!!!!! SOMEBODY HELP THEM!!!!!

    Reply

    Mary SF replied

    Back before the PVR or VHS a soap fan would have to watch every day and everything in order to get to the stuff they like. Part of the fun back them was watching the soap in a group and while the filler stuff was on we would do what we do now on this posts. We made fun of the ugly furniture or how lame the new guy’s hair cut was or during commercials guess what the next scene would be and what they would say. It was all apart of the soap experience. Not every episode can be a blockbuster or each week be like Sweeps week. Fortunately or unfortunately depending on your view most soap fans have the option now of tuning in only for the stories they like and tuning out the rest. It may be helpful for the viewer, but overall I think it is that type of viewing that change how the format is presented and contribute to the poorer quality product.

    Reply

  38. CTwildheart says:

    I for one really wish we would stop pitting the remaining four soaps against each other. Like MarySF said we all love these shows and this genre. I for one could care less which soap did better in the ratings against another soap – tell me how the soap did against the other daytime shows! I have been watching for 40 years myself and am saddened at how the daytime serial drama has been gutted. I may not like some of the plot points or characters on a show – but I haven’t stopped watching.

    Reply

  39. CTwildheart says:

    And DG do you have any comment of your own – or can you only comment on others?

    Reply

  40. susan M. says:

    GH is the best in my book!!!!! Love Tracy, Anna, Robert,Luke,John,Blair, even Todd ETC…………..

    Reply

  41. Ces says:

    I could never understand Y&R’s popularity. I have tried on several occasions in the past 25 years to watch this show and it bores me silly no matter who is at the helm. Peter Bergman bored me on AMC and he annoyed me the few times I watched him on Y&R.
    Being a fan of both GH & DAYS since the late 70′s and early 80′s – GH right now, is by far the best show in Daytime (not like there are many to choose from, but if I had to pick!) If they get rid of Kate/Connie, Christina, Britt and Sabrina then it will be damn near perfect!

    Reply

  42. robert says:

    This was why Maria Bell was fired. Agree with GH being the best soap right now.

    Reply

  43. moshane58 says:

    We all are soap fans not enemies here.We all have our picks.What is everyone’s problem..The ratings change all the time.I may only watch GH but hope all of them succeed.Lot to many already for cheap talk and cooking shows.My favorite is still AMC but I am baking the genre no matter what network its on.Everyone plese just back soaps and no replacement shows.Another one goes more will follow.

    Reply

  44. jp says:

    With airing only 9 episodes in 2012, OLTL should be named best soap. What they did in those two weeks can’t hold a candle to the rest. But I am loving GH right now. It is definitely the most improved show. I don’t always agree with Frank and Ron’s vision all the time, but they know how to use the history of the show and deliver a compelling story where all characters are involved in a fast moving pace.

    ABC just bring back ONE LIFE TO LIVE.

    Reply

  45. ashlee says:

    I agree. But to be fair and honest, GH had no competition. B and B told one story all year until Stephanies death took prominence. Young and the Restless was a complete mess until the new regime took over. And DAYS seemed to forget how to tell stories. After a very disappointing start, Cartini has made GH must see tv again. It kind of reminds me of the final months of AMC when so many dead characters were brought back. Im not complaining. Fans will accept any outrageous stories that undo the destructive rampage that Phelps and Guza inflicted on the show for the past decade. It just goes to show that soaps have not created enough characters that the audience cares about since the 80‘s and 90‘s, and they have to bring them back. GH currently has an embarrassment of riches in the veteran department, and the audience responds to characters they know and love. Its a shame so many soaps had to die to make the powers that be decided to give the audience what they want!

    Reply

  46. Gamblerchick says:

    The most buzzing show, on the Internet is the BEST SHOW. IN DAYTIME and that show is GENERAL HOSPITAL. And there are a little few, things they need to improve on. 1.) KATE/CONNIE 2.) BRINGING ON MORE VETS 3.) MAKING THE RELATIONSHIPS ENEW, AND FRESH ( SABRINA AND PATRICK, LIZ WITH SOMEONE NEW PROBABLY THE NEW GUY. OR BRINGING LUCKY BACK. 4.) GET RID OF THE LESS TALENTED (BRITT, TREY, FAISON) People who’s talent is a waste. 5.) LESS OF SONNY, AND MORE OF THE CORE FAMALIES. ( THE QUATERMAINE’s and THE SPENCER’S) They need more focus on the core FAMALIES that they have done, with the QUATERMAINE’s so far. These points are lacking on the soap. And the least buzzing show, is the least and the disappointing show. IN DAYTIME WHICH IS: BOLD AND THE BEAUTIFUL. This soap is just a mess: with Liam and Hope and Steffy triangle. And Brooke going after, every men that Taylor ever had, (Ridge) and Stephanie had (ERIC,THORNE) and now she’s going after her own sister’s husband (BILL). WHY CAN’T SHE EVER SETTLE. WITH JUST ONE MAN. And I wonder where Hope has picked this from. With the same man that she and steffy, ever had first OLIVER and now LIAM. AND SHE HAD STEFFY’s brother THOMAS. I think these two need HELP. There is one thing that, was SPECTACULAR WAS STEPHANIE’S DEATH ON MONDAY. May be they could 1.) ERIC AND BROOKE AGAIN. Instead of making a mess,for her sister . Like she has for, Taylor with Ridge. Katie doesn’t deserve that. She has been through too much with her depression.

    Reply

  47. Jan says:

    I can’t say OLTL was the great good bye because it should have stayed.

    Reply

  48. Donna Schreck says:

    GH ,especially the anniversary and the Nurses Ball were the best ever. Very rewarding for all the fans. Kate/Connie has got to go she just doesn’t fit in. BandB could tie with Y and R for most disappointing. OLTL may have had a good farewell but nothing can beat GL. And that’s the show that should come back.

    Reply

Leave a comment