News - Soap Buzz

256 November 23rd, 2015 THE YOUNG AND THE RESTLESS: Just Why Is Dr. Anderson Perpetrating This Heinous Plot Taking Baby Christian To Give To Sharon?

Courtesy/CBS

The Young and the Restless has certainly not been afraid, or shied away from bombshell, and sometimes twisted and outlandish plot points under head writer and executive producer, Chuck Pratt Jr.

This lastest one involving Sharon (Sharon Case) being drugged to believe she is pregnant by the evil Dr. Anderson (Elizabeth Bogush) is about to come off the rails this week on the number one soap opera.

But the question is, just what on earth is Dr. Anderson’s issue?  Who is she truly in a vendetta against?  Why did she kidnap baby Christian and want to make Sage (Kelly Sullivan) and Nick (Joshua Morrow) believe their baby died, meanwhile drug inducing a fragile Sharon while she was supposed to be seeking mental health treatment?

Courtesy/CBS

While we are waiting for Dylan (Steve Burton) to wise up and figure out what is being perpetrated on Sharon, and Nick and Sage, it looks like Sharon will be convinced that she gave birth to this child and raise Christian as her own!  But won’t it eventually be revealed to be Sage and Nick’s … err, Sage and Adam’s (Justin Hartley)?  Some members in the viewing audiences now are thinking that this  story down the line might somehow reunite and intersect “Shadam” – Sharon and Adam, if Sharon were raising Adam’s child, and he found out about it.

But this time, for once, can Sharon rebuke that this baby is hers? Can she be a heroine that will fight back and figure out what has been done to her by this horrific doctor? 

Share your thoughts in the comment below on this story below: What or who do you think Dr. Anderson’s vendettta is against?  Would you like to see Sharon figure this out on her own?  Are you angry, hating, confused, or loving this storyline?

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

  1. Timmm says:

    Dr. Anderson hates Nick for being this rich little punk that daddy cleaned things up for him when the good [bad] doctor broke her neck years ago at a Newman pool party! ANYONE in Nicks radar will pay! The thing I hate most about this story is Dylan! He is Superman now at the PCPD. FINALLY Paul told him the other day he is NOT a cop! But anyway, Dylan is working on this suck azz story involving Devon and he is figuring things out that no one else can figure out, ie, the GCPD! However, in Dullan’s own life he cannot see that Sharon is being bamboozled? Who in their right mind would let the mother of your baby sit in a facility and accept he is NOT allowed to visit! Those face time chats are a joke!

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Oh, yeah, Timmm. Superman, indeed…..and so smart. Such a dunce!!!!. Today, he shouldered his way into Dr. Neville’s place. No civilian can do that and get away with it. That is a violation of someone’s civil rights; even if he were a cop, without probable cause….unless there is a warrant of some kind. The PTB surely get away with a lot, as much as the GCPD…lol.
    Then, of course, Sharon ‘had’ the baby. Dr. Anderson can placate Sharon….easily. She is on another planet, full of barbiturates. Will she be able to pacify Dillon? What will be the excuse the doc will give family members about not being able to see the baby? What about lactation? What about the expulsion of ‘after’ birth?….for an entire month!!!!! Sharon has had kids, so she knows the drill, however, she’s in oblivion. Oh, yeah…she needs to remain ‘imprisoned’. If Sharon sees Dillon, he’s so stupid, he’ll accept anything that may be out of the ordinary, and/or whatever the doc feeds him. If the baby were a different race, the doc would explain that away somehow, and Dullard would tilt his head to the side for a nanosecond, making us think….’hey, he’s not buying this…he’s figuring it out”….but, golly gee; nothing concrete in that brain. He will stare for a sec and then nod his head in acceptance. Hey, Timmm, maybe he will surprise us all and figure it out …..well, when elephants nest in trees….we shall see. Bye, luv-ya.

    Reply

    Timmm replied

    I have to laugh, its like when Sam breaks into these places, most recently at Nicholas’s castle, she pulls out her little tool, inserts it into the hole, Whamo, door open! Is she really that good? PS: Ceecee, get your mind out of the gutter!

    Harry replied

    Right, Sharon has had two babies so she knows how her body feels after giving birth. Moreover, how is Dr Quack going to make Sharon lactate or rather yet, explain why she is not lactating?
    Today, Nicholas and Sage ran into Dr Quack and she started going off the rails about how horrid the Newman family is and she repeated information Sharon gave her during their sessions.
    I was waiting for both Nick and Sage to remark upon the fact that she wasn’t acting like a psychiatrist by violating doctor/patient confidentiality but instead those two morons became all defensive and angry.

    CeeCee replied

    @Timmm.
    Hey, lol. How is my mind in the gutter? I’m talking about Sharon. HaHa….Timmm, my love…this is Y&R…..have you had a few? Kidding. Was my mind in the gutter? Which time? Lol. The gutter makes the world go ’round!!!!! ‘Nite.

    CeeCee replied

    @Harry.
    Exactly, Harry. A doctor cannot break a patient’s confidentiality….no any, no how. Hippocratic Oath and all that jazz. The doctor WILL prevent everyone from seeing Sharon and the baby, for the obvious reasons. She will take her sweet time. I am just anxiously waiting for the reason she will give. Another nonsensical one, begging for a ‘HUH?’ moment.
    Nick’s and Sage’s dander went up because the Newman name was bruised. Poor, poor Newmans! Awwww, Harry! Suddenly, the family has now become Sage’s. How nice….for how long?
    This storyline is stupid, sad and depressing. No one is happy; I said this before. My gosh; Christmas is coming!!!!!!!! But, the actors are really doing their best with what is given them. Except for Steve B. I think he’s overdoing it. It seems that he goes in head first, more than is required of him. Just sayin’ I don’t know. He just does not do it for me….same category as Burgess and the other guy, Stitch.

    carol replied

    Harry, she has had at least 4 babies, Casey, Caseys missing twin, and Nicks 2. I have watched longer than 50% of this casts real time life! One of the things I liked about it was the story lines were more believable than other soaps. Example, poor girl becomes rich mans wife…while under c pratt, there are at least 3 story lines that are nonsense. .the cast are being great, and our reason for following!! C pratt should go back to the first 2 decades and study the storylines. What a great job was done with alcoholism, marriage, and love. Pratt needs to be locked up with those files until he gets Iit!! Todays world I could give a great real life story of how a man stalks, using so much technology, gps, hacking, lies, all to break a woman just because she stood up to him. He takes years, and at times nearly wins, as the law will not help until she is hurt physically. The law simply says they have not caught up to how to protect against technology.
    This is todays world, and y&r have made a mark in taking real problems and bringing them to light to make a difference……that is what we want to see again, not nonsense. we love our cast and want them to continue…but this fan wants pratt to be locked up with the archives until he gets it or step down, or, put someone in there that does get it!

    Eileen Hargis replied

    He has to play the script. He doesnt write this crap, hes just acts it out.

    CeeCee replied

    @Eileen Hargis.
    Really? I did not know that. Thanks for enlightening me.
    When we, the audience write a comment, it is logically implied and directed toward the writing….not the actor! What is it that you want me to say, Eileen? Of course, I will criticize idiotic writing and action. You have a happy day.

    Sammie Jo replied

    And to top it off, they’re having sex less than a week after delivery. Rule of thumb is 6 weeks.

    Ashley Benzyl replied

    Well, always has seemed that Nikki is an airhead,and with Dylan being her
    biological son, there has to be something rubbing off, no???

    MBmomof3 replied

    Yep. What Timmm said.

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Timmm said my mind was in the gutter. You think so, too, MB? Double LOL.

    Harry replied

    Carol. yes, of course you’re right–Sharon had four babies including the twins!
    So even more reason for her to know that her body would feel like she got hit with a semi truck after giving birth.

    MBmomof3 replied

    Ha! No CeeCee I think your mind is just fine. But I think Timmm’s original post is completely accurate. I don’t know which story I hate more…Nick/Sage/Sharon/Dr./Babyswitch or the Winters’ debacle. Just yuck to both of them.

    CeeCee replied

    I know, MB. Just kidding; as is Timmm. I know Timmmloves me….we go back and forth teasing each other.
    And, I agree with both of you about the cray cray storylines.

    Chrystie_Delancey replied

    Ha! Paul is not a cop either … at least not a good one anymore.

    Why don’t they put Dylan through the academy and actually have a story about the rigors of that? It is so much easier to make him an Insta cop just like Jason Morgan became an Insta hitman. This is crap writing at its finest. Where is my writing job?!

    Reply

    Rose replied

    Speaking of Paul, why isn’t he investigating Dr. Anderson with a vengeance about how his sister could just walk out of the mental facility, and maybe (or maybe not) die in Inferno 2? Where’s Christine when you need a pit-bull prosecutor to go after her?

    CeeCee replied

    Exactly, Chrystie. There’s a storyline right there. But, according to our dear Su, there are no stories to be had. These writers seem to have a one-track mind, thinking inside the box.

    Timmm replied

    I know, at least on GH they are putting Valerie through the academy. Although, I dont know that “Cadets” go undercover their first night out! No PT, no classroom work? I know, its a soap!

    k/kay replied

    Just remember no matter what stupid stuff goes down Sharon will be the bad guy I swear it has to be personal against the actress that’s why I got so fed up I really tried to watch it but I can’t keep replacing TV’s by throwing my shoes at them.

    MBmomof3 replied

    I completely agree. If they are going to make Dylan InstaCop at least put him through the academy. Another insult to Wisconsin. We are not fans of Chicago sports teams, (we have our own thankyouverymuch) and we require training of our law enforcement. Either Police Academy training or Criminal Justice degrees. We don’t let daddy’s barista son play cop cause he’s bored schlepping coffee. Dylan being a veteran works in his favor to become law enforcement, but the fact that he has PTSD would likely make him ineligible. The Stupid. It burns.

    A. Simmons replied

    I think this is the most ridiculous story line that has ever been on Y&R because it really truly insults the viewers intelligence I don’t care how crazy sharon is there is no way she cannot tell that she has had a baby without her being totally out of her mind and if she is that much out of her mind then how come her family doesn’t know about it and what family member would not go to see their family member in a mental institution for this long they would break down the door before they would not be allowed to go see them I know I would!

    Wilda replied

    Because he and Sharon decided it would be too dangerous. He was going to go thru the academy; but it changed. LOL

    Ashley Benzyl replied

    Well, who actually is this writer anyway???

    julia replied

    i really dont like how this story line is going its making me not want to watch the show anymore, why would you do this to dylan again and chelese loves adam she knows they slept together she will understand give sage her baby back this is not right and let that dumb ass sharon have her kid sharon sjould of been played out the shows years ago she sickening to watch .

    Reply

    Regina replied

    Girl I agree they need to leave Adam alone they are doing to much .let Adam be happy with Chelsea the story line is whack.the baby should be Nick and sage baby .I think everyone need to start likeing Adam more and let someone else play the bad guy role.I think sage and Nick make a great couple.better then him and Sharon.

  2. Rob says:

    GOD. PLEASE. MAKE. IT. STOP.

    Reply

    Joey replied

    I think this is sick. And I think this can’t go on for a long time I think it needs to come out with a blood test this sucks I have never been so disappointed

    Reply

    Joey replied

    Well this how dumb this is Sharon does not know don’t you have milk leaking or other things going on that women have after having a child and you’re telling me Dylan doesn’t realize this either no milk league is none of this none of that and by the way don’t you get a friend afterwards you know your red headed one this is how stupid this whole thing is I love this show but this is good against stupid

    Reply

  3. elm51 says:

    this is one asinine storyline – i have lost interest………………….

    Reply

    Gino replied

    Me too, very boring storyline. It put me to sleep lol. I will stick with Days Of Our Lives. The storylines are wonderful and acting terrific.

    Reply

    Joey replied

    I have watched Y&R since I was 13 teenage please let it end on great note! !!!!

    Reply

    Joey replied

    Oh and then the orderlies know that Sharon was never pregnant this is so stupid she had the baby there in the hospital don’t you think people would ask this is also very stupid

    Reply

  4. Iakovos says:

    Here is my WHY question… Why are we subject to another baby switch game involving Sharon? We had to suffer through that train wreck of a plot involving Victor, Ashley, Adam and who all else when Faith was born. This line of story is redundant and does nothing to serve or develop characters. Rather, it only moves pieces on the game board, only in no real direction. I am growing tired of the near incest and the repeating tales. Give these attractive older (40ish! Not kids!) something real and meaningful to do. Give me some romance and true joy regarding bringing a child into the world. At least allow Sharon to evolve into a stronger woman again. She was once a scrapy young woman, a survivor. Let’s see this come back. Is my Soap Opera Santa listening to me? :-)

    Reply

    Lucia replied

    YES to everything you wrote. Thank you.

    Reply

    Wilda replied

    Double ditto~!~!~ :)

    Laurie replied

    Iakovos,

    I hear what you are saying. This writer seems to like weak women-he’s already sent Phyllis, Sharon & Sage to Fairview-all in separate sl’s & for different reasons. All of this is less than a year. Why do no men ever crack & get stuck in there? Because women are weak, crazy & needy is what I hear when he does this. He’s also had Hilary held hostage for months-Jack, too, but of course he’s not a woman.

    It’s stunning to me how Y&R is showing these decades old s/l plots, like Carol said earlier-do something MODERN!! Current issues. I think a possible terrorist fear would be too heavy, but the cyber stalking is a good idea. How bout instead of kidnapping Sage’s baby or killing Sharon’s, have one of them suffer from postpartum depression & not understand it at first but feel unattached to their baby. Bring some music back like in the Danny Romalotti days. Music never goes out of style. Bring on a few talented artists on & have them do cameo’s performing on the show. Just no more dopplegangers & baby switches. Next Ashley will be pregnant. This show, and some others TBH, pay not attention to age & keep knocking up the almost 40′s (Sage), the over 40′s & 45+’s like Sharon & Christine. They COULD get pregnant at these ages but it’s risky & a slim chance, but then to have them all do so at the same time is ridiculous. The writers seem to not realize age when writing these sl’s. Phyllis is 20 yrs younger than Jack, but wait, as Marco, his story was that Marisa was love of his life-she’s a good 35 yrs younger than he-she must have been 16 when she met him!!! Now she’s w/Noah who is 30+ yrs younger than Marco. They pay no attn to age & such.

    Reply

  5. Kelly says:

    I hate this story line with a passion. End it now. Give Sage back her baby, rescue Sharon ad put Dr Anderson in prison. Be done with it.

    Reply

    missy replied

    Love your answer Kelly. Nice and succinct. :)
    They just keep recycling old plots.

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Right? Unreal and tiresome; this story is, Kelly.

    Reply

    su0000 replied

    I gotta laugh when people same ol’ plots..
    After 40-50 years of daily stories there really is nothing left that hasn’t been done.
    Anyone have a plot that has never been used ? ..
    and can run for at least 4 months are not bore everyone..

    But ya, I could give a hoot about Dr. Anderson and Sharon’s freak-out.

    Harry replied

    Yes, the only way this story can be salvaged is if they end it ASAP and hopefully, have Sharon go against how she has been written time and time again. Please have her realize what Dr Anderson has done and please make her return the baby to Sage.

    CeeCee replied

    @su0000.
    Well, susu….go ahead and have a good laugh. But, as someone else has mentioned….how old should Cassie be now? And, Mariah? Their twenties? How old is Noah, Faith and now Christian? Sharon has been pregnant four times, albeit Christian is not hers, she was pregnant and lost the baby. Every one of these births was surrounded by drama. Why?
    There are plenty of storylines that have yet to be written. They’re just lazy or not have enough of a vast imagination. Bye.

    CeeCee replied

    @Harry.
    Hello, a real. H,
    What if Anderson and Neville are associates, somehow….working together? The bad thing about it would be that Michael’s tenure is a short stint….that’s disappointing. I do not like this, at all.
    I hope Knight stays for a long time. Perhaps, ‘they’ will make him a good doctor working for the greater good. His experimental drugs meant for the good of mankind….oh, well! Dreamin’, I’m always dreamin’…LOL.

    CeeCee replied

    @Harry:
    I KNOW I wrote, “Hello, Mr. H”, but what I got was “Hello a real H”. Go figure, Harry. I hope this correction goes through. I apologize.

    DYLAN replied

    Cassie (and Mariah), in real time of what has aired on the show, was born in 1993. That would make them about 22. However, in a seriously screwed up move by the writers, Summer (who was rapidly aged), is now about 21 or 22. We ALL know, because it has been said over and over and over again, that Summer was born AFTER Cassie died, and Cassie was 15 when she died. So that, logically, would put Cassie and Mariah at about age 38. Making Sharon and Nick about 54….making Nikki at least 79, and making Victor about 94. That would be real. We just have to accept that soaps exist in a strange time/space continuum, where adults do not age (heck, All My Children was attempting to say that Erica was 30 in 1993….having been raped at 14, and given birth to 16 year old Kendall), but kids do. Where else could you have 42 year old Gina Tognoni (Phyllis) acting as mother to 36 year old Michael Graziadei (Daniel)? LOL. To beat that, Kassie DePaiva playing Eve on Days of our Lives, is actually two years older than the actress (Karen Moncrieff) who played Eve’s mother many years ago. When Days of Our Lives aged Scotty Banning in 1989, that placed beloved Alice Horton at over 100 years old, as he was her great-grandchild! LOL. There are SO many more bizarre instances of Rapid Aging, where if you work out the timeline using real life logic, they would drive you bonkers. Like EJ on DAYS…he was born in 1997….9 years later, in 2006, he was 30. Will, Sami’s son, was born 2 years BEFORE EJ, in 1995. I could go on and on, and likely will at some point, but not now. :)

    Wilda replied

    Has Y & R done a gay story line; or transgender? With all the hype of Caitlin Jenner; someone should have picked that up and ran with it big time. I just joined the Y & R when AMC/OLTL shut down; so don’t know all the back stories. To me the order of birth would be Mariah/Carrie? (I forgot her name already LOL); then Noah; then Faith; and she lost the last one. Dylan sure gets the short end of the stick when it comes to paternity lol

    CeeCee replied

    @Wilda.
    Hi, Wilda,
    Yes, Y&R has attempted to do a gay storyline. Rafe Torres, played by Yani Gellman, was a gay lawyer, a really upstanding, nice guy. Chris Engen, the original Adam Wilson ( now Adam Newman), walked off the stage because he did not want to get touchy-freely with another man. But, this story was not intended to make Adam gay, but to use Rafe for his own dastardly deeds. Enter, Michael Muhney, who had no problem getting involved in a gay relationship. So, Adam had sex with Rafe. But, when Rafe found out Adam’s scheme to blackmail him, I believe Rafe was heartbroken and left. I am not sure if I am remembering the reason for leaving correctly, Wilda. Let’s just say that this attempt at a gay storyline amounted to naught.
    Y&R is too wrapped up in using Sharon as a football to introduce any new idea/story to pique our interest. Besides, there are too many audience members, and perhaps, TPTB themselves, to deal with anything ‘gay’……too much sand around in which to bury their heads.

    JUDY K replied

    AGREE…HORRIBLE SICK STORY……END IT SOON PLEASE!!!!!

    Reply

    Timmm replied

    Amen! Its like the whole Neil and Devon story, you knew right from the beginning it would suck and it gores on and on AND then they drug daytime legend Michel E. Knight into this fiasco! End BOTH of these stupid stories!

    Reply

    cars tell a douglas replied

    I agree..let sage have some joy and happiness with her newborn baby that she loves and need..she don’t have a real family! !

    Reply

    Kathy replied

    I have just got involved, what happen to Sharron real baby? I am so tired of trying to figure this out.

    Reply

  6. Debbie Cyparski says:

    I have to agree I am sick of this storyline. What are the writers thinking, or should I say not thinking. This is the same story as Faith be given to Ashley by Adam. Between dopplegangers and baby stealing Y & R is becoming the same old same old.

    Reply

    Kathy replied

    I second it!

    Reply

  7. Mary SF says:

    I think anyone who was paying attention has already figured Dr. Anderson is either the girl who was injured at that pool party, OR at the very least related to her. There was no reason for that made up after the fact tidbit of Nick’s life to come out unless the show was planning on using it one day. Now if they could make her somehow related to that Moxley family as well that would tie all these unrelated characters together to perhaps form a new family rivalry for the Newman to fight beside the Abbotts. The only thing I hope they don’t do is have this Dr. Anderson be one of Ian Ward’s minions.
    And like the article states if Sharon raising Adam’s baby get those two characters back into each other lives that will be the only good reason to subject Sharon to yet another stolen baby story—

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    I like the way you think, Mary. Timmm was actually the first to mention that Anderson was a scorned schoolmate of Nick’…..socially persona non grata, ‘pool’ girl.
    The introduction of the Moxleys makes a lot of sense, Mary. I have/had actually been hoping that Judge Moxley was Gabe Bingham’s mother….who is still alive with Jason Thompson’s face, LOL. But, it doesn’t seem to be that way. I won’t give up, though….like a dog with a bone; just like Kiki being Nina’s daughter….it will happen. It’s written in the soap stars.
    As far as Sharon? I am still befuddled why everything negative lands on her doorstep. Why her? Poor Sharon. She can’t catch a break. Look to whom she is engaged….the hulk.

    Reply

    davlestev1 replied

    I’m on the episodes but not all the way caught up..i know she was given a fake baby bump but it had to be removed..has no one noticed AT ALL??? Is Sharon so high she believes she has a pregnant belly..was the actual notice of pregnancy glossed over so CP can sit behind his desk..look at the ratings numbers and laugh evilly?

    Mary SF replied

    Thanks CeeCee I like how you think too– never give up on Kiki being Nina’s daugther, it will come out sooner or later. As for Judge Moxley being Gabe’s mother wouldn’t she have noticed Adam looked like her son? I guess if she hadn’t seen him for a while she might not, but on any soap nothing is out the realm of possibility, like if she had affair with Victor back in the day, maybe Gabe was Victor’s son and she gave the child to the Binghams who friends of hers who had been childless, then Victor found out and destroy the Bingham’s company– now that would be a twist.

    CeeCee replied

    @davlestev1.
    Hi, dav,
    It is confusing, is it not? This baby bump imagery may be one of three things. Sharon may have experienced an hysterical pregnancy, which is a very real psychological malady. This is why she could also feel the baby kick….all in the head. It does happen. Secondly, Sharon is so pumped full of mind-altering drugs that it is what she sees through the power of suggestion….and, thirdly, Anderson put a ‘prosthetic’ bump on Sharon while sleeping. I suppose the good ole doc began getting careless and was slacking, since it appeared to me none of the staff really knows what’s up her sleeve. Hearing that Sharon became distraught and fit to be tied, as reported by the nurse, who had to sedate her, the doc was forced to produce a baby for Sharon….enter, Christian. It also seems that only the other weird nurse, who took care of Christian, knows. I do not understand how stupid these writers think we are. Really? What will they fabricate for the sudden appearance of a baby? The rest of the staff never saw Sharon pregnant. How about the howling of labor pains? The birth? The OBGYN? Is Dr. Anderson so powerfully polarizing? So proficient in all fields and multitasking?…..or, is she drugging the entire facility just to get back at the Newmans? What a farce! My six year old son wouldn’t even buy this drivel! Later.

    CeeCee replied

    @Mary SF.
    Hi,
    Yes, Mary, Elise would have noticed. But, as I stated a couple of weeks ago, I think she is aware of what happened as she has been taking care of Gabe secretly. Lol, Mary. It is all speculation and fantasy on my part. I want Jason Thompson to be the real Gabe, after facial reconstruction, of course.
    However, now that I think of it, if Elise gave her illegitimate child away, then, she would not know what Gabe would have looked like. I know…me and my crazy thoughts!!!!

  8. MEG says:

    i’m sure Sharon will turn out to be a heroine ,and Dylan her knight ,Dylan will also find out about Neville .he is a good cop.this baby is nicks ,and nick is gong to have to take responsibility for what made dr Anderson go off the rails for what his family did to hers,Sage Sharon and Dylan ARE THE VICTIMS HERE,

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Dylan is not a cop. I bet he didn’t even graduate High School, MEG. Yeah, all Dylan needs is chain mail, hauberk and a complete suit of armor; on his steed ( who’s probably smarter than he); lance in hand. He surely fits and looks the part. Poor Sharon.
    I think Sage will be the heroine. Why? Because as soon as she sees that baby, her maternal instincts will kick in. And if they don’t? Well, something’s very wrong with TPTB way of thinking. Just sayin’.

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Ps. Please forgive me for being a nuisance, but I do not believe Nick is responsible for that deranged doc’s actions. We are all responsible for our own actions. No one is holding her at gun-point to practice crazy medicine. Do we really know the full story here? They are all victims, one way or another.
    As far as Dylan, everyone knows about Neville, it was a matter of finding him. If this were real life and Dylan were indeed, a cop? Neville would have recourse in getting out of any trouble because the Neanderthal man barreled his way in. But, because Dylan is a layman, Neville could press charges. Obviously he will not do that since he has much to lose…but, it would serve Dylan right if he went down. Would Dylan get away with all this farce if he were not the chief’s son? In whose world? Lordy, Lord, such inane, senseless, useless storyline.

    su0000 replied

    Dylan shouldn’t even have a gun, as police have, he has PTSD..
    remember when he kidnapped Conor and was back in war freaking out cray cray..
    Anyways, Dylan is being written as an annoying snoop lol
    He has no right to question anybody..
    If Dylan came to question me I’d say.. ”sure yah ok, you kidding me, get your pretend cop game out of here go away”
    People are more than stupid to even talk with Dylan ahaaa so lame..

    Harry replied

    Off topic but LOVED the scenes today which transpired between Michael Knight and Steve Burton. I can see that those two also enjoy working with each other.
    Burton seemed like Jason Morgan today when he kicked down the door to get to Dr Neville. Neville says to Jason, er, I mean, Dylan, “I don’t appreciate you kicking down my door like a cowboy on steroids.”

    CeeCee replied

    @Harry.
    Ha, Harry! Truer words were never spoken. Cowboy on steroids, indeed. You cannot get more a’ la Michael Knight than that. I love him.
    I must admit, I did see a sort of camaraderie between the two. Happy Thanksgiving.

  9. Mo says:

    Sharon is not being drugged to believe “she is pregnant by Dr. Anderson”. She is being drugged by Dr. Anderson so she’ll believe she is pregnant. Watch sentence structure.

    I thought maybe Dr. Anderson is doing this because she wants Nick and by having Christian die it might break Sage and Nick up and then Dr. A can move in.

    I feel bad for Dylan–second child that is not his. And if the baby is Adam’s-second child of his that he didn’t get to name! But at least he was at the birth.

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Hey, Mo. I get it…very clever of you. I think Anderson is doing this because it gives her a sense of power over a very powerful family. What a twisted brain she has. She could be Victor’s spawn, actually. She enjoys playing with the lives of those whom, she believes, have hurt her. Bogush is truly doing an over-the-top job. So good at it, I believe what she says. She is also sort of a plain Jane, which makes the role that much more credible…..always the wall-flower? Just sayin’. Lol.
    Unless TPTB humanize Dylan; oil his rusty joints? I feel no pity for him. He gets on my nerves. Thank goodness he left GH before I started watching. Later.

    Reply

    Timmm replied

    Its weird because its been so long ago and its not like she is ringing a register at Walmart, shes a freakin doctor! Why revenge now? The actress is doing a good job. [Maybe Stitch will take some notes?} Anyway, Steve was good on GH because he was a Robothug, yes one of Sonny’s, I know how you feel about that BUT Jason was never asked to tackle much as Jason Morgan. I liked him. Here with his buddy Jill, he sucks, the character, I mean.

    CeeCee replied

    @Mo.
    Hi, Mo,
    Yes, that would be the way for Dylan to go…the Police Academy. However, Su brought up an excellent point. Dylan suffers PTSD, as Su said. Realistically, he should never be able to join the force. What would he do every time he suspects someone of wrong doing? Shoot first and ask questions later? He would be declared mentally unstable because of it.

    Harry replied

    Mo, that reminds me of an old Groucho Marx joke. “This morning I got up and discovered an elephant in my pajamas How he fit into my pajamas I will never understand.”

    Reply

    Mo replied

    LOL

    It would make the story more interesting if Sharon did believe she were pregnant by Dr. A. ;-)

    I like Dylan a bit more since he’s been with Sharon, but having him play Superman is so ridick. Overall though, I do find him boring. He either needs to go back to the coffee house, enroll in the police academy, get his PI license, or quit being the go-to man for crime. At least Marissa and Luca haven’t been on-screen lately. Of course, now I say it, they will be.

  10. Jenny Brooks says:

    I just continue to hope that Y&R survives Chuck Pratt. He is a menace to soaps. This story is so awful I can hardly bear to watch it. The only good thing this soap has going for it is Justin Hartley (Adam) and these writers stick him jail instead of finding a way to show that someone else hit and killed Delia and that Adam just ran over her scarf later.

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Absolute sense that makes, right, Jenny? But, I think Adam was jailed just so the bosses could harvest our sympathy by the beatings he’s getting in there. LOL. As you say, I agree that ‘thing’ with the scarf happened just that way.

    Reply

  11. Vicki Black says:

    I wouldn’t dare second guess Chuck Pratt . . . but would love for Sage to get her Christian back. Good must win occasionally – Lord knows we need a win these days with the world falling apart.

    Reply

  12. Geena says:

    The only reason I’m still hanging on is Adam & Chelsea. If they get ruined by this baby plot, I will be out of here. It’s pretty clear to me that they have zero respect for the character Sharon. She is nothing but a plot point and a joke to make their new pet Sage the lead heroine . It’s not lost on me that this newbie gets Nadia’s theme played for her over and over again as if I’m supposed to care. Day after day of mourning. Meanwhile, what kind of meaningful scenes does Sharon get? Nothing.

    Reply

  13. Teighlor says:

    Elise is her mother

    Reply

    DR replied

    And Victor is her father.

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Ewwww. DR….That means Sage is sleeping with her brother? Even TPTB would not go that far. Excuse me while I go throw up. Lol.
    What’s more of a fitting twist in the plot would be if Gabe were still alive as Elise’s and Victor’s son. Elise gave him up for adoption and the Bingham’s adopted Gabe. After the accident which killed Delia, Gabe had plastic surgery…..and, I bet Sage knows all this. Jason Thompson will play Gabe, Lol…I know, I know, I sound like a broken record. Forgive me?

    Karen replied

    But that would make her sister to Nick and Adam! Yikes

  14. k/kay says:

    This is the second storyline concerning a baby switch for the character of Sharon 2009 the Faith story. Everyone of my friends who still watch absolutely hate the show so I told them quit bitching and quit watching it like I did do not want to hear it. Case has been getting crap stories for years but she still has a paycheck so she probably just laughs and says it is a job. The reason I quit is because it is insulting to people with mental illness and I also know somehow after all is said and done Nick will be blaming all this mess on Sharon. I now know why Jessica Collins/Avery left the building.

    Reply

    Mary SF replied

    Actually it is her third stolen baby story– Faith was stolen from her and given to Ashley. Mariah was stolen from her by Ian Ward nurse follower, now Sharon has been given a baby stolen from Nick and Sage. I don’t hate this story, I accept soaps repeat stories all the time, how can you not after forty plus years, but what makes it absurd is the same type of story keeps happening to the same characters.

    Reply

    Lucia replied

    Exactly. Surely we can do more with Sharon’s character than make her have these traumatic birth stories.

    Mo replied

    You could say fourth if you consider Cassie as well.

    I don’t like that they are doing the story with Sharon as she had her baby stolen and given to Ashley fairly recently. And that Dylan will now have a second child taken from him.

    k/kay replied

    Why would you feel anything for a character Sage who has been on a year in a forced relationship with the character of Nick and she is getting tons of air time every recap I read she is on just like Dylan still has his nose in everybody’s storyline. When Ashley lost her baby and still thought she was pregnant she never left the ranch to see a Doctor. I mean would Superman Dylan not check with her Doctor before she admitted herself to the hospital would the Doctor not do a follow up after the miscarriage . Oh well as everybody says Pratt wants Sharon crazy!

  15. penny says:

    The stories they have going on right now are insulting. One minute you have characters who come across as Sherlock Holmes than minutes later these same characters are dumb as dirt.

    Reply

  16. Scoma60 says:

    I am so sick of Sharon being thrown under the bus. She’s being held captive and abused. I’m sick of Pratt’s perverse ideas regarding mental illness. BiPolar Disorder does not make you insane. It’s highly treatable yet YR likes either abusing Sharon or treating her like a pariah.

    Reply

    Chrystie_Delancey replied

    It’s like what they are doing to Elizabeth Webber on GH. Here you have two characters that were LONG established on their prospective shows only to be tossed aside in favor of those that have been on less (i.e., Phyllis and Sage for Y&R and Sam and Carly for GH). It sickens me.

    Reply

    mlgh replied

    Carly was on GH before Elizabeth. Carly came to Port Charles in 1996 and Liz came in 1997. You can have Sam, though. She came a whole 6 year later. If you can’t tell that’s sarcasm. Sage being favored over Sharon when Sharon has been on Y&R a LOT longer is nowhere near the same as someone who was on before Liz and one who came 6 years later, but has been on since. Not even close to being the same argument.

  17. Lexie says:

    I don’t care for this storyline at all either. It seems Y&R writers recycle storylines a lot lately. Are the writers, producers, and directors assuming their audience isn’t paying attention. Wake up we are! I’m tired of Sharon being victimized by the Newman’s, becoming their collateral damage. The character (Sharon) use to be strong when she was with Nick until Cassie died and Nick turned his back on her. This character went downhill after that. Sharon needs to be made strong again. Nick is a carbon copy of Victor just not ruthless like Victor. Victor used Sharon for his motives when he married her. It wasn’t because he was in love with her. The only reason Victor doesn’t get along with Adam is because Adam is very much like him. When he sees Adam he sees himself. Just think if those two could come together and be on the same side just once, Victor might see what Adam is really made of when it comes to business. Maybe Victor will start to respect Adam just a little. Victor thinks everybody is out to get him. Should Victor be worried, since “what goes around, comes around”? Umm.. Y&R writers are you reading any of this? You have a lot of cleaning up to do!

    Reply

    Chrystie_Delancey replied

    You are right, Lexie. Nick is a moron, whereas Victor is not, he is just vile and does everything in the name of family whereas Nick’s motives are down south.

    So many characters need an overhaul. So sad.

    Reply

  18. Beth says:

    Very simple. JFP did this storyline on GH. It is called recycle.

    Reply

    su0000 replied

    hi Beth..
    that (type) story has been used to death on all the soaps..
    Babies are drama tools ..
    ALL the soaps are total ”recycled”
    I highly doubt any writers could write a plot that is not worn out..

    Reply

  19. Mateo says:

    I don’t know if any of you realize this but Chuck Pratt wrote for Melrose Place in the 90′s. Almost every one of his stories are direct rip offs of the plots he told on that show. Sharon’s “baby” very similar to the Jo’s baby is dead and then re-discovered almost a year later. The Dr. Anderson character is almost a direct rip off of Dr. Kimberly Shaw character. All these complaints about how tired everyone is of the stories and here Y&R is still the #1 show and gaining in viewership. Apparently all those complaints are not being listened to because the numbers are STILL growing. Don’t get it twisted. I think the story is beyond ridiculous. Nevermind that Sharon has to be WAY beyond child bearing years but how about the evil doctor being the only one on staff at a HUGE mental facility. In those environments you never see just one doctor. Nevermind receive all those mind altering drugs. Dylan is so stupid to not even recognize all the things wrong. You would think he would tire of being lied to by people. And Mariah, doesn’t she even care about her mother’s condition? She was the only one who knew the entire truth and she hasn’t even visited, or attempted to visit her “mom”. I need Mariah to get in there and kick that sorry excuse of a doctor to the curb. Dylan can’t save a lady in a wheelchair but Mariah can save the world.

    Reply

    DYLAN replied

    If ONLY Pratt would do Melrose Place rip-offs on this show!! His Melrose Place was serious water cooler talk back in the day!! It was fun and fresh, and campy, and soapy, and had viewers on the edge of their seats. I don’t get why Pratt, who has done really great work like that in primetime, cannot do the same in daytime. So many things just don’t make sense. Why the Sage adoration???? This is a character connected to no one, and in under a year, she has snagged two of the show’s leading men, had a baby supposedly die, gets Emmy reel scenes on an almost daily basis, gets the show’s iconic theme song played in alternate versions for her. What’s her last name on the show? Does anyone even know?? And Why the Dylan hero worship? I feel REALLY bad for Steve Burton!!! On GH, and on this show, he just did his job. At first viewers loved him, but then thanks to the constant shoving of the character down our throats, and his bizarre insertion into EVERY single plot as the savior (even though he was a brain damaged murderer), viewers turned on the ACTOR, instead of the character, or the writers. Now they are doing the same thing with Dylan. Settle the pace a bit, have him go into the Police Academy, and then realistically give him a reason to be running around town like he is jacked up on Kryptonite. And I can’t even believe what the writers keep doing to Sharon. They must REALLY hate Sharon Case over there to keep throwing her under bus after bus after bus. She admirably plays whatever story they throw at her, somehow managing to salvage the often times disgusting and disturbing plot twists they foist on her character. There was a time when she was an Emmy winning industry darling, and her character was a leading heroine on the show. But before we all cdrucify Pratt, let’s not forget that his brand of shlock daytime writing has serious precedents set by the man that so many praise…that being Mr. Bill Bell. Let not any of us forget the absurd storyline from 1991 in which Lauren was pregnant by Scott, but managed to avoid him for 9 months in the same city, and he didn’t even know she was pregnant….and then she gave birth, and whacko Sheila (Kimberly Shaw the first, if you will), was able to switch her dead baby with Lauren’s baby, etc. etc. And Sheila has been hailed as one of the greatest villainesses of the daytime genre, even though the writing was complete and utter plot driven crap, there was never any motivation or reason for the character’s over the top villainous actions, and her snarly acting style was seriously one-note (although Kimberlin Brown did what was asked of her in the role). If we all look at this realistically, Pratt is really not doing anything different than Bill Bell did on Y and R…and he should!

    Reply

    Mateo replied

    As far as Steve Burton is concerned, he is Jill Farren Phelps pool boy and can do no wrong in her eyes. That is her one request of Pratt that he feature him in EVERYTHING. He is one of the few actors that will do Ms Phelps bidding. Bill Bell did some crazy storytelling but he managed to pace it very slowly. I remember when I first started watching Y&R my joke was I could miss a week of the show, before DVR’s, and it would still be the same day and perhaps all the characters would be having lunch by then. Now we get 25 plot devices thrown at us in one day and they are NEVER solved. In fact they assume the viewers forget a lot. What Pratt does is treat his audience like idiots. He has said before that he hates daytime drama and its viewers and writes solely for his own pleasure. His current story with Sharon Newman is proof that he thinks viewers are idiots. Sharon is way past child bearing years and self committed herself to an asylum. She knew she wasn’t pregnant when she went in and then suddenly she advanced in pregnancy some 9 months in less than a month. Then some strange doctor who manages to leave the asylum and practice at Memorial Hospital without any other doctor on duty back at Fairview. I hate the story because there is no reason for this story. The Dr Anderson character is evil just to be evil. No explanation. No background. Just a baby stealing, drug pimping psycho with NO reason. As for Sage, her last name is Warner. I like her character but lately she has been overacting with the loss of baby Christian. Typical Pratt behavior – overkill. I generally have liked Y&R in the past because they told detailed stories. Now it’s just showoff material with characters no one cares about. If it wasn’t for Justin Hartley (Adam) and Melissa Clare Egan (Chelsea) I probably would consider skipping the show altogether.

    Rose replied

    Dylan could meet up with Valerie (GH) at the police academy. Actually some crossover scenes between Y&R and GH might be fun. Don’t think it’s been done before.

  20. damien says:

    i know nick s been busy with his own personal problems but why hasn t he stopped by the hospital once to visit the mother of his children, has nt faith expressed that she misses her mother? ….. another example of pratt s plot over characterization!
    …furthermore with avery gone, and dylan being propped as the new younger paul williams, the character suffers from overkill. time for dylan to be off our screens for a bit!
    at the end of the day, nick and sharon belong together not dyaln and sharon. bs

    Reply

    Mo replied

    Sharon has a no visitors order that Dr. A coerced her into signing. That’s why you see her communicating with Dylan online. It’s done so people won’t see she’s not pregnant.

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Agreed, damien!!

    Reply

  21. randy says:

    ! can put this quite simply,,Bill Bell is rolling in his grave,,,,If he could see this train wreck now..What they have done to this once power house of a soap opera is down right shameful ,,how any writer or team of writers who have written this show in the last 7 years can hold there head up and be proud of one storyline they have dished out is beyond me…steve burton must shake his head in disgust when he gets each script..sharon case must be feeling so much deja view she probably feels drugged for real…lets not even go on the neil and hillary crap they are shoveling this way,,,,devon is a waste of air time,,,thank goodnes for justin heartly ,,im sure for many viwers he is the only reason to tune in,, ,

    Reply

    Jenny Brooks replied

    Amen, Randy. I agree with you on everything except Steve Burton. That dude left GH to follow his friend JFP and get the schedule he wanted. He got everything he wanted.

    Reply

    DYLAN replied

    Hi Randy. I wish I had read your post before I wrote mine!! I agree with several of your points, but please read my post regarding Bill Bell. I hope you will agree somewhat with what I wrote. I also touch on Steve Burton, and Sharon Case, in ways I think you will agree with.

    Reply

    Ashley Benzyl replied

    So that’s it!! I do recall that the fellow who wrote Y & R was named Bell. It is now
    this Chuck Pratt, you guys say. Hmm. Explains every thing.

    Reply

  22. Chrystie_Delancey says:

    Ugh. How many times can Sharon be mixed up in a messed up/switched at birth story?

    Let’s see – there was Mariah being kidnapped and raised by a cult follower for many years. Then there was her baby being switched with Ashley’s. Not to mention giving away Cassie. Now this?! As if Sharon even needs another child. She is probably the least deserving right there with Victoria who can never wait to get back to work once the baby is out.

    What a waste for Sharon Newman and Sharon Case. Can’t she play sane anymore?

    Reply

    su0000 replied

    Well, that is what Sharon is used for, babie mess up stories..
    She is the designated messed up freak out character.. it is her role since 2000 up LOL

    Sharon is bipolar and there is no cure..
    Sharon is just a dropped pill away from freak-out anytime they need a cray cray story Sharon is on!

    Reply

  23. Bobbi Bird says:

    Personally. I think Sharon should demand a blood test at the hospital where it can be done in a real lab. She should also let Nick know about the fact that she doesn’t remember being in labor. Nick and Sage can also have blood drawn. Then they will get Christian Andrew Newman back with his real parents. Please make this happen Sharon doesn’t deserve to be blamed for this. She is innocent, she was heavily drugged. Very out of it from the amount of drugs Dr. Anderson has been forcing her to take.Neil needs to have the doc charged with negligence in taking care of Patti. Mariah knows it is to soon, even if Sharon was Pregnant.

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Good premise, Bobbi. But, Sharon is so enraptured, so over the moon for finally having a baby in her arms, she’s not thinking of anything except for ‘her’ bundle of joy. She is still not lucid….still under the influence……even to notice that her body is not in concert with the natural phenomenon of giving birth and/or its aftermath.
    Besides, at this point, there is no reason to question anything…..as far as she knows, nothing is awry.
    Furthermore, Anderson is her savior, not a villainess.
    We can only hope that the time or reckoning won’t come soon enough.

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    @Dylan.
    Thank you, Dylan. Despite the typos which autocorrect makes; I appreciate the fact that I did make my point.

  24. Chris says:

    So beyond stupid. The show should be called the young and the vengeful. Every single thing on this show is based on revenge. There is nothing that is reasonable on the show. Nobody acts like anybody would act in real life. Everything has become totally stupid.

    I have been watching this since I was a kid and it’s
    Dumber than it has ever been. I don’t expect a soap opera to be realistic. But it would be nice if on occasion people acted like people in real life might. Women who should be intelligent are morons. There are couples on the show that nobody gives a crap about like Abby and Ben. No one light meal with the Hillery and now we have to deal with them again? The writers couldn’t care less about the actual characters. I understood Neil wanting to get some revenge but they took it so far and destroyed the character. And the writers obviously have no idea how to write strong women. What in the world happened to Filos? She came out of her coma With an entirely different personality. The actress portraying her is really good and could portray Phyllis the way Michelle Stafford did.

    Now we have yet another baby switch? Come on! how stupid. We’re supposed to believe that Sharon doesn’t realize she did not give birth?

    I started watching General Hospital after some of the young and the restless best actors went to that show. It is so much better written. There are strong women and many of the characters are more realistic. People on that show do things that make sense. Many women are written as mature and not pathetic and love sick like YR. I could go on and on. I will stop here. It’s just really, really tragic to see how bad the writing on YR has become. But that said, I think ratings are up and so I imagine we will continue to be subjected to idiotic characters, weak women and stupid storylines. :-(

    Reply

    DYLAN replied

    I agree with many of your points. But, strong women on GH?!? LOL. Women on GH are narcissistic, desperate mob molls who have no value or worth aside from whichever mobster du jour they are sleeping with. These women are so pathetic, they extol the virtues and sing the praises of some mobsters (Sonny, Jason, Johnny, etc etc), while simultaneously calling others bad (Julian, Carrrlos, Paul, etc). Carly appears strong, but she is really just loud and obnoxious. Sonny threatened to murder her two years ago. Jason repeatedly threatened to have Sam rubbed out back in the day. I guess that passes for foreplay with these brain dead women. Monica is a strong woman. She has had four children, some biological, some not, and they have ALL died, some more than once. But that’s it for strong women on GH. Well, and Alice, but she is a wrestler. Naturally she is strong.

    Reply

    Rose replied

    Add Epiphany for a stronger character.

  25. Gloria says:

    Can you tell me what the deal is with the girl and the pool party incident. I don’t remember ever watching at that time that happened

    Reply

    Mo replied

    It wasn’t shown on-screen. Just mentioned by Sharon. As I recall there was a pool party that Nick threw. There was alcohol. A girl I guess was diving in the pool or fell in and broke her neck. Victor smoothed things over with the cops and the girl’s fam–I guess by throwing money around.

    Reply

    DYLAN replied

    It must have happened on a Saturday….. when the soaps don’t air, and no one ever mentions the word “weekend”. In my memory, Sharon was occupied in high school being raped by Matt Clark, fending him off, falling in love with Nick, etc. If the show needed a villain from that era, why not tie it into history? Joe Clark even has the same last name as Matt Clark, for goodness sake. Soaps have such rich history, these writers do not need to make it up!!

    Mo replied

    Now I remember, I think the girl was jumping into the pool from the balcony or something like that.

    I keep waiting for them to reveal that Joe Clark is Matt’s bro. I didn’t watch back then, but why don’t they reveal that? Or why doesn’t Sharon say, Clark, are you related to…? Or when they were investigating Joe Clark for Avery’s rape, why didn’t it come up about his brother, if it is his brother? I don’t get it.

    Mary SF replied

    This is was a recent made up event by this writing team, — it came out when Nick was going to take Faith away from Sharon for the millionth time and Sharon used this detail to blackmail Nick into allowing her to share custody. At the this pool party, Nick dared or encouraged this girl to jump from the balcony into the pool. She was seriously injured and his father covered it up and paid off the family as well. We are assuming that Dr. Anderson is that girl, or at least someone related to her, but as of yet, the show hasn’t said.

    Reply

  26. Theresa says:

    Hate this storyline. I’m a labor nurse and this whole line is dispicable. The writers need help. There is nothing realistic about any of this. So disappointed!

    Reply

    su0000 replied

    Well, Theresa..
    Soaps are highly fictional, far out stuff / entertainment.
    Soaps are grownup fairy tales, and all the characters live in soap land.. lol

    Reply

  27. Wendy - Vancouver says:

    Doc. Anderson is a so-called professional doctor and isn’t honest, ethical or moral in any way.
    The Doc. (forget his name) who was working at Memorial is now fired, is dishonest, unethical, immoral and practicing medicine illegally AND from a motel yet!
    Sharon is a mother to Faith, yet given the storyline of victim as having bi-polar (which is not really being depicted accurately at all) in an institution for the mentally ill, yet being kept ‘captive’ and drugged. She’s now supposed to have had a baby, but having delivered previously would know she hadn’t since her tush isn’t ‘feeling’ like she delivered. Like a woman would know that for sure.
    Dylan is ?replacing the police force of GC seemingly single-handed these days. The police chief has everyone and their dog reporting the mundane to him, (doesn’t he have more to do than be a gossip centre?) thus has seemingly forgotten about being the owner of Crimson Lights.
    So, here we have professionals being degraded, (even the two nurses of the Devon, Neil, Hilary storyline are stealing both medications, babies and assisting with kidnappings.) and being represented as evil, immoral individuals so unlike in the real world.
    The police are being dissed totally with the Dylan plot, as if they can’t/don’t solve crime.
    Sharon is being made to play victim (so like the usual Pratt make the woman out to be useless, incompetent in various way, criminal, etc) with mental illness not being depicted in a respectful manner at all.
    Seems to me nearly every single character now on YR is incompetent, evil, nasty, adulterous, devious, criminal. Who on the cast now is acting anywhere near true to their original characters? Maybe Victor, although he’s grown more evil in his controlling behaviours over the past few years.
    Really miss the old YR where it would have gentle scenes, no over the top dramatic scenes like on the prime time crime shows, reduce the immorality among professionals for sure. Everything that’s going on seems like it’s disjointed from the past months in so many ways and like the writers just get together and say: What craziness shall we do next! Stop the craziness is what so many fans want.
    Find it’s impossible to keep track of where so many of the characters are emotional, as they flip from week to week.
    Just my opinion, for what it’s worth.

    Reply

    Ashley Benzyl replied

    Yeah, miss the old one also. For much the same reasons, illogical stuff all through the hour and a half. I mean get rea lll.

    Reply

  28. Wendy - Vancouver says:

    One correction to my comments above: Intended for the comment about “forgetting he own Crimson LIghts” is Dylan. And it seems he has forgotten. Also, where is Esther, now she’s working at C.L. she’s never seen at all!

    Reply

    Mo replied

    I was thinking that yesterday with the scene at CL–that Esther should have been in the background working, but it’s probably cheaper to have an extra.

    Reply

  29. SALLY says:

    Since when does a woman give birth to a baby and to drugged up not to feel it or be there for it???? REALLY?? FIRE THE WRITERS PHELPS AND PRATT!!!! They need to go YESTERDAY!!! THEY DON’T HOW TO WRITE OR PRODUCE OBVIOUSLY!!!! THE ACTORS ARE DOING THE BEST WITH WHAT THEY GOT!!!
    BUT, THESE LAME STORIES THE WRITERS KEEP THROWING AT THEM I’M SURPRISED IT DOESN’T PUT THE ACTORS TO SLEEP!!!! GET RID OF PHELPS AND PRATT PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Reply

    su0000 replied

    hi SALLY..
    The Y&R ratings keep going up and up..
    Seems millions are loving Y&R..
    Pratt is going nowhere..

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Su, sweetie. Let me understand this. It was not too long ago when you sang GH’s praises and threw dirt in Y&R’s eyes. You more or less said you despised Sharon, and not too keen on the soap. Correct me if I am wrong, ok? Which is it? Are you a turncoat? Lol. See, susu. I genuinely love Y&R, not because it’s number 1….but, because I always have. I could care less about the ratings. They mean nothing. I do not even believe the ratings.
    As far as soapland being the home for adult fairy tales? That’s all fine and well, however, fiction is ALWAYS based on reality. Any English Lit professor will tell you that. There is just so much a writer gets away with writing syfy/fantasy.
    You may sell that rubbish to yourself, Suzie Q, but not to many of us. I, as anyone else, needs the escape that entertainment may provide….for myself? It needs to be within reason. As I mentioned above (and as Theresa , a medical professional, has stated, no woman ever to grace this earth has given birth so silently, unless one is under anaesthetic, (C-section, as myself)…..yet, I still went through 6 hours of labor before the surgery.
    I will accept anything TPTB do, but I have to understand it….has to make sense. I question its validity, within a modicum of reason. We are dealing with real people, in real stories, written by soap writers, not Steven Spielberg.
    As Mary SF says: she is used to the recycled stories, accepts them; however, stop crucifying Sharon with these stolen babies theory/plot. What is the point of storytelling, if we know the outcome. No mystery, no suspense….soapland never was this drastic. Bye.

    DYLAN replied

    Cee Cee, as usual, your post is thoughtful, rational, and well written. :) I have just realized that all we can do with Su’s posts is laugh them off. He/she only types posts to rile people up, make them mad, and tick people off. I realized this just recently, when he/she made a post on another thread about the GH character Levi Dunkelman being well written. LMAO. That character was arguably the most pointless, worst written character in the history of the entire soap opera genre, and every post from every viewer on every message board echoed that sentiment…except Su. I actually have newfound respect for Su. He/she is bracing and polarizing, and definitely succeeds in getting people talking and typing.

    Tess replied

    Right, Sharon can’t tell she has had a baby. GIVE ME A BREAK! There are always painful signs. INCLUDING sore boobs that fill with milk. Sharon is too crazy to realize she has none?

    Reply

    Mary SF replied

    I don’t know if you would say she is crazy, but sometimes when a a person wants to believe something is true their bodies will begin to manifest that truth. It is possible the character Sharon body is displaying those signs to Sharon, even if the script isn’t saying that directly, as viewers it is reasonable assumption to make. It is the same one we had to make when Ashley “went into labor” and thought she gave birth, to Faith. Plus with the drugs and perhaps even being brainwashed by that doctor it is plausible for now Sharon would believe she gave birth. But hopefully, the writers will have Sharon clue in at some point, and when she figures out this isn’t her baby, let’s all pray the writers will allow this character to come clean and not try to keep a baby that isn’t hers.

    CeeCee replied

    Tess, we are talking about a mentally, dissociative disorder. And, there is such a thing as an hysterical pregnancy. As Mary says, the body starts functioning as the mind dictates. However, Sharon does have lucid moments. It is during those moments that she should not have a few questions for the doctor, but also questioning why she does not feel the painful ramifications of having had a baby. Mariah and Dylan are both novices when it comes to babies…..they are oblivious. Anderson is still managing to drug her , soooo…..
    The idea is being carried too far. How could Sharon not have any memory of the birth? She had the baby in her sleep? These are all questions/facts what will eventually arise….how to explain, though?
    Tired of it, and want it over. Poor Sage; poor Sharon, as the mothers. Four hearts broken. And, if we include Adam? Five. I think these writers went to THE SCHOOL OF ‘LE MARQUIS DE SADE’.

    Ashley Benzyl replied

    Pu lea sse, get rid of them and clean this story up!!!

    Reply

  30. Averie says:

    I think this Dr. Anderson is related to the girl Nick raped years ago. Maybe she’s a sister or relative.
    I so wish the writers, for once, would let a female be a heroine and figure something out. How much fun would THAT be to watch Sharon figure it out and pretend in order to catch the doc? But these writers are so predictable. And God knows how long it will take for all of this to unfold to the point that one of the characters involved figures out who Christian belongs to.

    Reply

  31. Lucia says:

    I miss Gloria.

    Reply

    MBmomof3 replied

    I do too. I’d take a storyline with Gloria over this current dreck any day.

    Reply

    Wendy - Vancouver replied

    Me too. Often comment that on Twitter. And miss Jess, Beth too.

    Reply

    Eileen Hargis replied

    Beth is headed back for the holidays, yea!!!

    Mo replied

    AMEN! Gloria is who got me hooked on the show in the first place.

    Reply

    Lucia replied

    HIp hip hooray! I’ve been missing those jangling necklaces and bracelets, those bulging eyes, those tiger print dresses…oh, Glo. You’ve been under-appreciated!

  32. Perren says:

    I wish to correct an earlier comment Sharon has not had two babies, she has had four (that I can remember) they are Cassie, her twin Mariah, Noah, and Faith. I have to say the whole baby switching thing is about played out
    though and as for the not so good Dr. Anderson as to her motives don’t know/don’t care I’m just ready to see her admitted as a patient at Fairview already, although it has to be the worst mental health facility to ever exist even in a soap. People seem to break in and out without any security personnel even noticing. Honestly I love Y&R but sometimes it feels like we as viewers are expected to suspend disbelief just a little too much.

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Sharon has been pregnant 4 times, Perren: Cassie and Mariah; Noah; Faith, and her latest pregnancy with Dylan, where she miscarried.

    Reply

    DYLAN replied

    I beg to differ. This mental health facility looks like Johns Hopkins compared to the ones on General Hospital, where patients can roam the halls freely, cavort in each other’s rooms, come and go as they please, have weapons of choice at their disposal, and bite people’s ears off.

    Reply

    Rose replied

    Dylan…back to Su wanting to raise hackles…I thought about this a while back, especially with the Levi quote. I did bite the other day and did ask why did she watch soaps anyway since her “tastes” see to run counter to the spirit of our “love in the afternoon” stories. No reply.

  33. Tess says:

    Sharon will only be raising this baby until his eyesight goes bad. Then all hell will break loose and Sharon will end up in the same crazy nut house. Chelsea will dump Adam, Dylan will dump Sharon and here we go again. Sorry, I don’t agree with the match-up. Adam’s fire is with Chelsea.

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Excellent point, Tess. Wow! How true!!!!! If Christian is, indeed, Adam’s, his vision may be compromised by the congenital disease. Good one!!

    Reply

  34. Tess says:

    Tell me, does anyone reading this actually know any families that have been through ANY of this junk? NO

    Reply

    su0000 replied

    That’s why it is a soap- not real life..
    that’s why when people’s lives get unbelievably crazy messed up they say ”I think I’m living in a soap opera” … lol

    Reply

  35. Mo says:

    If Sharon gave birth, surely she would feel some residual pain, soreness. And after you give birth, your stomach doesn’t go back to pre-baby. There are tell-tale signs and Sharon having given birth three time previously would know (even if she was drugged the first time). Is the same writer also writing Abby on Days giving birth to a way premature baby in a cabin and it survives okay?

    Is Dr. A going to stop drugging Sharon now?

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Not only all that, Mo. But there is the after birth ‘flow’ for about a month, off and on.

    Reply

    Mo replied

    And what about when Sharon wants to breastfeed and can’t because there’s no milk. Or when she goes to her ob/gyn and says, I didn’t miscarry after all!!! Nah nah nah. Or when another ob/gyn checks her over and says you didn’t just give birth. Where’d you get that baby from? Is Dr. A going to say she delivered the baby? And it couldn’t have been delivered vaginally as Sharon would have had to participate and she was drugged and for a C-section there would be an incision. So many loose ends.

    CeeCee replied

    @Mo.
    Hi, Mo.
    Lactation was actually the first thing I mentioned. She should be feeding the baby immediately. She should be ‘leaking’ by now. Doesn’t she realize that?
    There would not only be a scar with a Caesarean Section, there would also be pain and be on her back for a time. I have had three C-sections; trust me, I know…lol. This is soooo ridiculous. I want to bang my head against the wall and grit my teeth in frustration.

    Katy replied

    I agree with you

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    PS.
    The doc will probably also say, she has been giving Sharon pills to dry out her milk

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Lol, Mo. Funny you should mention Abby. There were about fifty of us gathered at my parents’s house yesterday. All the women….(friends and family) watch Days. My sister’s sister-in-law’s comment was, “yup, Abby had a premie that weighed about thirty pounds.”
    How realistic was that? This was her first baby?….it surely came out sooooo easily considering the rustic ambiance.
    I have said it many times before; Sharon’s predicament is offensive to us and to the actress.This, among others, is DICK AND JANE storytelling.

    Reply

  36. Iakovos says:

    So many serials — daytime or primetime (Shondaland)– seem to rely on crackpot characters and crazy plot lines for over-the-top moments, they forget the true characters and the kind of stories the genre tells best. Shows like SCANDAL, HOW TO GET AWAY… even daytime left-of-centers like PASSIONS and DARK SHADOWS… cannot sustain themselves on idiot tales.

    Reply

    Rose replied

    And it seems most of the shows you mentioned are all from ABC. Not very Disney like.

    Reply

  37. Rob says:

    I don’t know what’s more heinous, the plot or the acting. Everyone involved seems to be sleep walking through this story and rightfully so. BUT, next to Amnesiac Hilary this is Shakespeare.

    Reply

  38. Kim says:

    Very stupid!!!! How rhe heck does she not know rhat she had a baby.. Being a mom …you know.. B.. When Nick and Sage see the baby.. Duhhh i am sure they will recongnize him as it only has been 2 weeks since he did not pass away… I would know my child… Mariah knew she was not pregnant.. This is gonna drag on for months.. Bad story line.. They all look like morons… This my only soap i watch… Dont drag this out give him back to parents… Sharon lied….

    Reply

    Harry replied

    Kim, today DR Anderson told Mariah that Sharon’s doctor was wrong when she told her she had suffered from a miscarriage.
    Mariah just nods her head stupidly. It’s kind of hard to be wrong about a miscarriage.
    What I hate about this story is that it makes everyone involved look incredibly stupid.

    Reply

    su0000 replied

    .. true fiction..
    She surely would notice she is not sore
    and
    not able to breastfeed ..
    LOL gotta luv it..

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Hi, Kim,
    Mariah did know Sharon miscarried. However, it was later confirmed by Anderson, I believe, that Sharon conceived again. Remember she was timing her sexual encounters with Dylan so she could get pregnant? The good doc took advantage of Sharon’s mental instability and ran with it. So, Mariah believed her mother was pregnant again. Isn’t it amazing how all these events just happened and fell into place at just the right moment. Complete manipulation and highjacking by the writers.

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    I had forgotten. Harry is right. Anderson did say Sharon never miscarried. I remember now. Sharon did lie to Mariah saying she had conceived again….but that was way back when. It is so hard to keep all these stories/lies aligned. Lol.

  39. Joma says:

    Is this a do over for Faith?

    Reply

  40. LYNN says:

    This is sick to do someone like this don’t care about watching this anymore. why dont you shut down the show if your going to make it that sick. You all don’t know by doing seen like this could happen in real life. i dont care about this show anymore.

    Reply

  41. charlotte oden says:

    I hate this storyline. I think Nick truly loves Sage and I want to see them together. Sharon is a screwoff and needs to find out on her own and give that baby back to Nick and Sage. She should get the correct mental treatment she needs because if she doesnt, and tries to pass off the baby as hers………….Dylan will find out it is Nick’s……….and that will be the end of Sharon. Nick will not love her ever, ever, again even as a friend. As far a Dr. Anderson, she is in love with Nick. That is my theory and knows she cannot ever have him. This is tearing my heart out for Sage. Please give her her baby back.

    Reply

  42. charlotte oden says:

    I am watching less and less because it is so dumb. Please…..get back on track. This show has lost its class!

    Reply

  43. nina Constante says:

    Get rid of that dr anderson .let devon have hillary .

    Reply

  44. christiine k says:

    so, this is the young girl that fell off Nicks father’s roof. This is a revenge plot. I could tell from the little talk in the hallway that there is a past. Its not about Sharon at all, Sharon is a victim. This will blow up. Watch the baby have Adams eye problem.

    Reply

  45. Wendy - Vancouver says:

    After reading all these comments, not one is at all complimentary except for the actors doing a great job with story lines which do not match their previously developed characters in most cases, i have a question.
    What are the qualifications of those who are actually writing the scripts. Are they all under say 30 and have no clue of the history of the show. Do they ever actually watch the show itself? Or maybe they just all sit down, don’t care anything other than churning out a new plot which is not really attached to the last one. Remember the fire? Well, that’s all forgotten except for Stitch being in hospital for awhile as he lusts over Ashley all the while planning to marry Abby. How truly stupid is that plot. And now with Lily begin seduced again by Joe, what about her children, who she’s always saying that she’s got to consider the twins! She’s always flitting around without them now. Guess they’ll end up being with an evil nanny who is related to Dr. Anderson.
    Heck, I could write for YR now!

    Reply

    DYLAN replied

    Soap writers under 30?!?!?! LOL. Most of them are collecting Pensions already!

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    LOL, Dylan. I think these writers must have lived through such sedate, dull and uneventful youth, that they now live it vicariously through their fantastical writing.

  46. Katy says:

    I think Sharron needs to detox these drugs an d figure out she did not give birth.

    there is more to lactating and other issues when you give birth. lets get real here.

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    That is exactly what I implied when I said, “the aftermath” of birthing a child. Of course, there’s a lot more that involved with the body…..goes without saying. No need to patronize. So, I think all of us ‘got real’, Katy….not just you. I am sure most of us women on these boards have had babies.

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Should read: …a lot more that IS involved with the body….

  47. Debbie M says:

    Ok I must of missed the day Adam became Christians father and does Sage know.

    Reply

  48. Tara says:

    I think Dr Anderson has something to do with Nicks past. Maybe a sister of the girl from the ranch years ago. I think she is out for Nick.

    Reply

  49. Yolanda Horton says:

    I hate it’s taking so long to free Adam and clear his name all these other things have come and gone why does Adam’s 3 have to be drug out so long and Dylan is Danny that he’s not realizing what’s going on with Sharron I do hope Sharron is the heroin and finds out that Dr Anderson is fishy and where is patty and please let Hillary in the wrong get back together

    Reply

  50. Vicki says:

    I would like to see Sharon fight back and eventually remember (once those drugs wear off) that she lost her baby and then she find out WHO Christian is and then SHE is the one who returns him to Nick and Sage and then it cleans the slate (for now anyway) with The Newmans so she can get a better story but of course Chuck Pratt will NEVER EVER let that happen. What if Dr. Anderson is Nick’s half sister (product of Elise and Vic’s affair) and this is REVENGE and she has known all along who she is and has been DENIED her birthright? Just a thought-She may think she is helping Sharon right a wrong when Nick went nuts about Schummer…LOL

    Reply

  51. Susan zoppi says:

    Nick and Safe should recognize their own child when they see the baby Sharon brings home. Certainly someone will figure out that Sharon didn’t have a baby because the baby she’s bringing home isn’t even a newborn. This has got to stop and Nick and Sage have to get their baby back! I can hardly stand to watch the show anymore

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    As I said days ago, Sage’s maternal instincts SHOULD stake over. A mother always SHOULD know her own baby. Natural phenomenon. I also said, that if it does not happen this way? Well, shame on these writers for changing the human makeup. Even animals know their young…..scent and instinct.

    Reply

    CeeCee replied

    Take over; not stake

  52. Cheryl Sirhan says:

    Give Nick and Sage back their baby. Put Dr. Anderson in the mental hospital

    Reply

  53. dori zoc says:

    DR. Anderson is the sister of the girl that Nick knew when he was a teenager. She was paralyzed when she was with Nick and APPARENTLY Sharon has known about this for years. APPARENTLY Victor threw money at the situation so that Nick would not get in trouble. THE stealing babies story line has been done before…Sharon/ Marcia, Sharon/ Faith and now Sage/Christian.

    Reply

    Cyndi replied

    I agree

    Reply

  54. Mateo says:

    In Pratt’s mind everything is related to Dylan or Ian. So here is the storyline: Adam is Ian’s son afterall. He really wasn’t infertile. The mother is Dr Anderson. They are all joined to take down Victor – because every bad thing is Victor’s fault. Judge Moxley is Ian’s ex-wife who wants to destroy Victor because he burned her in a business deal many years ago. Nikki and Paul are not Dylan’s parents. Dylan’s father is Ian as well so Adam and Dylan are twins separated at birth. Cain’s father is not Colin but rather Ian who had an affair with Genevieve in Australia back when Ian was running his cult there. HIlary is Ian’s daughter from his affair with an African American Nanny back when he was in Zimbabwe. Lily is Hilary’s sister and Devon’s as well which explains why she won’t stay with Devon — incest you know. Dylan has an inner drive to find his real father. He knows it isn’t Paul. It’s Ian. Dr Anderson wants to get to know her son again so she is giving him a son that he’s always wanted. She hates Victor (doesn’t everyone?) and wants revenge against that evil family. Did I mention that Faith, Mariah and Noah are really not Newmans but they all belong to Ian. Because Ian is the father of everyone on the show. At least according to Pratt.

    Reply

    Rose replied

    Mateo…your imagination’s working overtime. You and JimL should compare notes.

    Reply

  55. alaina says:

    the entire story has been crazy lately and has made me not want to watch it any longer

    Reply

  56. CSense says:

    A solution to save YR is to fire both CP and JP and they can take Kelly S. and Steve B with them. They can take Hunter King and bring back the other young lady who acted in the role first.
    If they bring back Josh Griffith than as many of the audiences suggested he should get both the head writer and executive producer job. Jill have power over Chuck to changed the writings for her friends Steve and Kelly. Every single characters who interacted with Jill’s pets treated them like they’re perfect. Sharon for the billionth times run over by the bus again for Sage and Dylan. Hated what they done to Paul and Neil don’t know who they are on screen so not them. Dylan is in every damn story lines and it’s becoming a bore. Sage with Faith make some people feel sick to their stomach. Faith doesn’t like this witch.

    Reply

    4ever DAYS replied

    I can understand why several people want Josh Griffith back at Y&R. He’s an excellent writer. DAYS is very happy with him and he is very happy at DAYS and most DAYS viewers are happy with Josh who has been a fan of DAYS for many years…It shows in his writing!

    Too bad, Y&R…Josh Griffith is very successful at DAYS!!!!!

    Reply

    CSense replied

    Who is the Executive Producer at Days? They sound like they’re dedicated to Days’s history like Josh Griffith is.

    4ever DAYS replied

    DAYS has three executive producers: Ken Corday, Greg Meng and Albert Alarr.

    Reply

  57. Cheryl says:

    I’m not a huge Dylan fan, but seriously, how many babies are they going to take away from this guy? Avery miscarried his baby, Chelsea lied and told him her baby was his, but wasn’t and now this baby isn’t his either? Time to give him a real family with a real baby that is his or do something else with his story line. I’m fed up with this story and also the Hillary/Devon/Neil/Gwen crap. I can’t stand Neil…maybe if he was played by a different guy…this one is ugly and I can’t stand watching him. Also tired of Adam being treated like garbage by everybody in that show! He didn’t mean to hit Delia and NOBODY blames Billy, (I don’t like the Burgess guy who plays him, either) Seriously, in real life, who leaves their little child in the car by themselves and especially after dark?!?!?! Then there is the whole Newman/Abbott feud…might as well be the Hatfield’s and McCoy’s. This has been going on for decades and is way past being old! I hate it that they took Sage’s baby from her, this will be another long, drawn out crappy story line. They need some new writers on this show…heck, everyone on this thread could write much better stories than the crap they are putting out now…it’s not really worth wasting an hour out of my day to watch it.

    Reply

    Lu Ann replied

    I agree with you.. newman/abbott has went on forever time to do something different. Sage started out with a strong story line and then they sunk her to this whiney person like Sharon.. I think Sage and Adam would be a great pair. Sage/Adam/Chelsea.. what a story line that would be… Get rid of Neil for sure Devon I cant stand him in and please kill of Hillary.. those 3 have no personality .. Gwen may end up having a good story line. as for Dr Anderson.. she is going to be Dillon or Sharon’s sister… Or Gab’s sister and she is mad at Nick for taking Sage away… I believe Gab hit the Delia… NOT ADAM… Leave Michael and Lauren together .. AND GET THAT CRICKET/CHRISTINA OFF THE SHOW. . SHE HAS NO ACTING ABILITY

    Reply

  58. Tiffany says:

    Anybody notice how all the Newman virtues are difficult? Children are born early and sickly or in the weirdest of places. no easy births.

    Reply

  59. Lu Ann says:

    Well. reading all of the comments.. I am thinking that Dr Anderson will turn out to be Sharon’s long lost sister and wants to see her happy or get in on the Newman loot. That would make since because she is “helping” Sharon and no one does that. Or she could be Dillon’s sister??? I am blasted that Nick an Sage don’t recognize their own baby for one. Two you never seen your baby’s body…??? REALLY. I know this is TV but it is an insult that the writers would go this far out… I agree with others that this story line has went on in the past and with Sharon.. WE ARE TIRED>.. just end this. And one more thing.. Does anyone really believe that Adam hit the little girl.. Police, doctors, Adam everyone is going by what Billy ” just told them”"” now one ever investigated this… there is NO PROOF… another story line in the making…. ? I think the one that hit the girl is Gab, he is the only one that they can spare to take off the show/Name.. And as smart as Adam is he has not investigated this??? And someone PLEASE get rid of Billy and Victoria… I cant stand either one of them. would not like them in real life… YUCK…And last.. Nickolas.. Well he started out having a strong personality and story lines. then they throw him to the wolfs.. and make him a wimp… And make JOE a knight in shinning armor.. he is talented and good looking. let him have some decent lines and time on the show… Just Saying

    Reply

    Mara replied

    LuAnn, Gabe is Adam. Gabe was not Gabe til after Delia was hit & killed & Billy & Adam were in the car accident.

    Reply

  60. Ann says:

    I’m tired of all the drama! This story has been done before and it takes too long for the truth to come out. Enough already! Let Nick and Sage have their baby before it grows up!!

    Reply

    Cyndi replied

    Nick isn’t the daddy.

    Reply

    Ann replied

    I know he’s not but this whole storyline is ridiculous!! It was done before with Adam switching babies between Sharon and Ashley and now again. They need to come up with some new ideas.

  61. Lu Ann says:

    CAN WE JUMP ON BOLD AND BEAUTIFUL… ONCE.. LETS SEE.. RICK AND MYRA HAVING A BABY…?? I KNOW YOU CAN HAVE MALE/FEMALE CHANGES BUT I DID NOT KNOW A MALE/MALE COULD PRODUCE EGGS TO HAVE A BABY??? THAT TOOK SOME THOUGHT DIDNT IT.. OH WELL ITS TV

    Reply

  62. KMA says:

    I am very angry about this. Come on writers of Y&R what women doesn’t know she’s given birth after she’s done it 3 times previously! It also angers me becuse this will be the 3rd time Poor Dylan had lost a child. At least the first one was his w/Avery . How is this wonderful caring character going to deal with this when it comes out. I know I should be concerned with Sage but if she hadn’t been so selfish when she found Adam and made him into the love of her life, this wouldn’t be happening. I think she should have been on trial along with Adam bc she started all this whole MESS!

    Reply

  63. Lisa says:

    Hate this story line. Stealing babies should never be a story line.

    Reply

    Johnny replied

    I agree 200% , the whole plot is ridiculous for all the reasons listed above..what woman wouldn’t know if she did or didn’t have a baby omg please find new writers!!

    Reply

  64. jo-ann gonzales says:

    I M ANGRY THAT A BABY IS USED IN A PLOT OF KIDNAPPING. THANKS FOR THIS AVENUE>

    Reply

    Cyndi replied

    Sad storyline

    Reply

  65. laurelp52 says:

    I hated it from the start. Stupid number one. Destroying characters and their relationships. The Y & R writers have been going off the rails for a while now. It will be going the way of the tv series “lost”, they’ll be fighting alien monsters and then oops, cancelled!

    Reply

    PAT MAJOR replied

    I AGREE. I HATE THIS BABY CRAP AND FIND IS UNBEARABLY CRUEL TO EVERYONE. GET A GRIP AND START WRITING – FOR REAL – INSTEAD OF BORROWING FROM THE PAST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Reply

  66. Susan from San Antonio says:

    I have been watching Y&R since the first day it aired decades ago. I have seen actors come and go over the years. I have seen some storylines that were much better than others but this story line about Sharon being handed Sages real baby is just about the dumbest storyline they’ve ever come up with.
    It’s been done a hundred other ways with just a variations and different characters but it was quite predictable and continues to be quite boring.
    Disappointed with the current storylines Y&R. I would think the writers to do better than this.

    Reply

    PAT MAJOR replied

    I SO AGREE. AM TEMPTED NOT TO WATCH UNTIL THIS BABY SWITCH IS OVER.

    Reply

  67. izzabo says:

    I totally agree. Have been watching Y&R for decades and am so disappointed with the laziness of the writing. Not a fan of how the writers have chosen to have key characters deal with unimaginable loss. And finally I’m tired of the drudging up of Delia’s tragic death and spinning another ridiculous story line or 5 around it.

    Reply

    Carolyn replied

    The writing is not only lazy, no innovative ideas. No creativity. JUST A BUNCH OF JUNK AND STUPID STUFF>

    I COULD DO A BETTER JOB. Hell Sharon could write better lines as a dumb blonde!!!

    Reply

  68. Cyndi says:

    Give Christian back to Sage. Very sad storyline.

    Reply

  69. Joeyr says:

    The story lines in this show us ridiculous. I have watched since this show began.
    I am so sick of sappy Sharon and dopey Dylan.
    How stupid can you be to think this baby is yours.
    Nick is the most gutless man I have ever seen. He does nothing about anything. He never disciplines that brat Fairh and how she treats people. I wish they would have gottenrid of her instead of Delia.
    Everyone lived her, no one likes bratty Faith. I cannot stand that child and the way Sharon and Nick explain
    things to her, barf.
    I am sick if the stolen babies and different fathers. It’s
    getting really old.
    Neil, Devon, Lily and Hillary are even more boring.
    End the story line it’s over and we are sick of it.
    I have never Devon and I like him even less now.
    I think it’s time to get rid of some of the actors and introduce new ones.
    I have stopped watching this show over 6 weeks ago and nothing has changed.
    Get on with it already.

    Reply

  70. Anna Woods says:

    I’m angry about this storyline. I want Nick to find out this is his son. Sharon needs to wake up. How can she believe she had a baby with no soeeness or milk. This is so dumb.

    Reply

  71. Jess says:

    I hate the storyline I think it’s horrible it’s like the Raiders have no creativity nothing’s been done before this hold baby still in Adam sharing Nick you just threw sage in the middle and then you have a preemie having stolen from his mother good or horrible insensitive storyline as many times as the writing all writers recycle storylines this one is probably the worst that I’ve seen in all my many years of watching.

    Reply

  72. Nancy says:

    I have watched this show for many years but not much anymore. The story lines are rediculous and stupid. what happened to writers of this show? So bad now!

    Reply

  73. milliebowers says:

    Hate this story line. anot possible in real life to not have symtoms after givng birth. Time to end this farce.

    Reply

  74. sherry says:

    I’m a big y & r fan, though, I’ve grown very tired of the Dr. Anderson storyline, lately it seems that it takes too long for things to be solved. Paul lost his touch on solving issues. Maybe, Mariah will make a good private investigator or officer, She’s the first to notice how Dr. Anderson always popping up around Nick or Sharon. When will they show Patti Williams, Marco. And I believe Paul’s son Ricky is still alive somewhere close.

    Reply

  75. Catherine Henderson says:

    I do not like it! I want Dylan to be happy, he is too kind and caring about others to get attached 2 a baby that’s not his. Also, I want Nick & Sage to get back together. Nick & Sage needs 2 deal with their loss together. And another thing…that evil Dr. Anderson needs 2 fall off a cliff or OD on the same drugs she gave Sharon. Have a good day!

    Reply

  76. Jewel p says:

    I’ve been watching this show since Nickie was a stripper it’s time to let nick and Sharon be happy and Adam and Victor bond

    Reply

  77. Jewel P says:

    I’m an old vet, I’ve been watching this soap since Nicky was a stripper, please let Nick and Sharon be happy and let Victor and Adam bond send Dylan back to General Hospital.

    Reply

  78. LindaB says:

    This whole story line is ridiculous! Sharon checks into the hospital for a 30 day period.

    She had just lost a baby and was trying to get pregnant, but wasn’t pregnant when she was admitted to the hospital.

    Dr. Anderson starts drugging her and tells her that she is pregnant during that 30 day period. Dr. Anderson then cuts off visits from Sharon’s friends/family to hide the fact that she isn’t “showing.”

    Even if Sharon had been pregnant upon admission to hospital, she would have been less then 3 months pregnant otherwise she would have been “showing”, or at least air head Dylan would have noticed a small pot belly on Sharon the way they were going at it like rabbits. Plus don’t forget that Avery was pregnant with Dylan’s child at one time and he was around for that pregnancy and loss. So he isn’t completely green to a woman being pregnant.

    For Sharon to have given birth to a full term baby, she would have had to have been in that mental hospital for 6 months if not longer. You’re telling me that a fiance or children would not press to find out why they are being denied visits other than “because Sharon said so” for 6 months or more?

    Then there is the matter of Christian, who was born severely premature to the point he couldn’t breathe on his own and was in NICU on a ventilator that was breathing for him. He was a severe preemie and extremely small with hands smaller than one of Nick’s fingers.

    We see Sage with Christian prior to her going to the benefit at Newman Towers. He is extremely small and still on the ventilator.

    While Nick and Sage are at the benefit, Dr. Anderson kidnaps the preemie. Remember, he weighs only a couple pounds and still can’t breathe without the aid of a ventilator. After the benefit/fire, Nick and Sage learn that while they were away, he went into respiratory distress due to his immature lungs and died.

    The next scene that shows the baby shows a full term infant in a bassinet. And a few episodes later, a full term healthy baby is being presented to Sharon. A preemie the size of Christian would have been in the NICU for months… up to 5 or 6 months before he gained enough lung function and weight to be released home. I’m a nurse and when Y&R takes on a medical story line, I absolutely cringe!!!

    Then there is the fact that a woman’s body goes through physical change and trauma during birth. There is bleeding, and breast fullness, lactation, physical checkups to check the height of the uterus to make sure it continues to shrink in size. None of that was happening to Sharon. Having given birth 3 times (Cassie/Mariah, Noah, and Faith), she should have and would have felt that physically things were different from her other 3 births. And Mariah isn’t stupid, she picks up on things, so she would even see that things were wrong. But here Sharon was handed a baby and just started bottle feeding it, when she had breast fed Noah.

    And then there is Dylan. He is a total hot head when it comes to everyone… except not being able to see Sharon for more than 6 months in a mental hospital. With that he completely accepts it. No question as to why 30 days stretched into 6 plus months.

    Dylan is not a cop and has no police background, yet for awhile he was involved in every police investigation in GC, despite not being a cop (which has to be a breach of some law). And then there is Paul. His father was a cop, chief of police actually. But Paul was never a police office, he was not involved in the police force, did not take police training etc. He was a private investigator who was hired by the police to help with one case. Yes, Paul was simply asked to be chief of police and accepted the job. ZERO police experience, training or climbing up in the ranks of the police force.

    Dylan was offered a job as a cop with the GCPD but turned it down so he could spend time with Sharon. Now Paul is yelling at Dylan telling him that he needs to stay out of police business because he is not a cop. Well Paul, technically neither are you ;)

    I don’t get Dr. Anderson’s angle. She didn’t kidnap a baby and give it to Sharon out of the kindness of her heart. She has some angle. It’s going to come out that she is someone from GC’s past who had plastic surgery and came back to seek revenge on Nick Newman or the other Newmans.

    Then there is Dr. Anderson’s complete lack of professionalism. She talks to everyone about everyone else, and no one seems to care that she is violating all kinds of privacy. Mariah is suspicious of the fact that “a few months ago” no one had heard of Dr. Anderson, yet there she is involved in everyone’s life and even attending Sharon’s wedding.

    Really stupid story line IMHO.

    Reply

  79. Lilly says:

    Give Sage and Nick back there baby ….Sharon already has had four Sage only the one it’s not fair that Sharon gets to keep this baby that is not hers ….I have watched the y& r when it first started…and this is the worst story line taking Sage and Nicks baby….I feel sorry for Dylan… not Sharon poor little Sharon always gets her way….I can’t believe everyone thinks that this is Sharon’s baby….let sage and Nick be happy with there baby…if it drags out to long I’m dropping the y&y and I know others feels the same….

    Reply

  80. mlgh says:

    I want Sharon to find out that the baby is Nick and Sage’s, give it back and go out of town for a while to recover. I’m so sick of the writers treating Sharon like the only scapegoat in town and making her the butt of every joke and every poor decision. The way they portray bipolar disorder on the show is a joke. It infuriates me that they continue to degrade Sharon Case so much. Did she piss Bell off? Is that why she’s consistently given horrible story lines to portray? They need to redeem her character and then leave her the hell alone.

    Reply

  81. Nikki says:

    I agree. I wish they would find another person to treat so badly. I am also sick to death of Victoria Newman. OMG Everybody has to be perfect for her to like but her crazy as hell father can get away with murder and it’s ok. My gosh I could make a list of crap he’s done even to his own kids and yet they always forgive him but they hold their spouses in a higher level. That spoiled brat Nick had a couple affairs on Sharon not to mention turning to Phyllis when Cassie died but he can’t forgive Sharon for changing Summer’s paternity. Isn’t that what he just did to Christian’s paternity?

    Reply

  82. kitty cat says:

    I believe that the Dr. was somehow infatuated with Nick while he was in High School and Nick did not notice her and she is upset about this and thus motive for taking the baby. She has been looking at old articles about Nick about how he was a “golden boy” and then there is this thing with Christian. If it all happens out , she will end up getting back at both Nick and Sharon. Nick will be losing the first few months or whatever with his baby (maybe even losing Sage) and Sharon will have to go through the agony of “losing” another baby.

    Reply

    Mara replied

    I read in another post that she was at a pool party at Nick’s when in HS & she fell & got injured & wants revenge??

    Reply

    Carolyn replied

    Nick didn’t want the crazy whimp!!!
    He was always in love with Sharon and still probably is!!

  83. Denise says:

    I think its way too drawn out and gets boring! You need to figure out how to speed it up a little bit and/or make Sharon or Nick suspicious of her and her motive for sticking her nose into Nick and sages relationship so often. maybe even have Sharon’s daughter figure out who dr. Anderson really is and team up with Kevin to do background checks and so forth, Just don’t make it so drawn out!

    Reply

  84. theresa says:

    I think it’s about time to everybody finds out who sullys parents really are how about that one

    Reply

  85. JW says:

    I believe Dr. Anderson had some relationship to the person that was killed while in the same fraternity as Nick. I too think Mariah should somehow discover that Sully is not Sharon’s baby. Where is Patty? And yes, in my opinion we were suppose to believe that months went by when Sage and Sharon were pregnant or not pregnant. You made Sharon seem so stupid. I missed the episode that showed Adam to be Sully’s father. That will most likely bring Sage and Adam back together, considering the way these stories go. Noah needs a new love in his life. He’s too young for Marissa. I may not continue watching unless we have some positive outcomes or something more realistic.

    Reply

    Carolyn replied

    DITTO!!!!

    Reply

  86. Dodie says:

    Truthfully, I am sick to death of the many storylines having to do with people taking other people’s babies. So sick, I am no longer watching. Come on, writers, surely you must have another original idea somewhere….. These baby stories are just overdone and boring…..

    Reply

  87. cathie says:

    Dr, Anderson is a very sick person. I hope this story line does not go on to long. Give the baby back to Sage and Nick, Sharron is nothing but trouble. Get rid of her. She does not deserve Dylan. I would also like to know why Dr. Anderson did this in the first place. I reallt do not like this story line.

    Reply

  88. Trish says:

    I don’t like using babies taken or lost and given to those other than their parents as an episode topic. This is long played out on Y and R. Sharon has no idea that this is not her child and Dylan is Laila land about the whole situation. Anyway, there is sooo much going on, not one person or family is exempt from “drama”.

    Reply

  89. Melinda says:

    Nick needs to figure out the baby is really his and he and Sage could be happily ever after. Sharon is crazy and doesn’t deserve to be happy. Nick does.

    Reply

    lorina Morgan replied

    I want Saga to have a happy ending with Nick. I would prefer the baby to be Nick and Saga. I can’t stand Sharon. I strongly Dylan and Sharon belong to each other. Also Adman and Chesle are fantastic together they have enough stress as it is. Come on stop with this baby confusion. I want to see stable relationship for once. Too many broke relationship in the real world. Give some kind of hope with your viewers.

    Reply

  90. marie says:

    young & restless need to nip DR Loopy (anderson) in the bud & expose her for what she is. someone needs to get wise to her and it should be nick to get paul to let kevin dig into who DR. LOOPY is. it has dragged on way too long and also this hillary and neil mess. also get rid of luca and melisa . also the kid of stitch needs to go ahead and accept abby. also write off ashley and dr, quack nibble. also the adam kidnap thing needs to end too. give billy and victoria a happy ending and victor the good guy for a change. also quit bringing back ones that left and dragging them back. if you are that bored with the writing of the program and running out of drama just take the story off.

    Reply

  91. Candace says:

    It didn’t take me long to figure out that Sandie Anderson is really Sandie Allen.
    While I don’t believe this jumping off the balcony ever actually happened on air – and was more of another twist on the whole Austin documentary debacle – I did remember Sharon saying the girls name was Sandie.
    In trying to figure out why Dr. Anderson was acting so bizarre I finally remembered the story of Sandie and the balcony.
    Can’t wait to see her true identity revealed and how she is no longer paralyzed.

    Ooh and BTW. The other investors who have Adam right now… Think Ian and Patty !!!!

    Reply

  92. Joeyr says:

    I have watched this show since it first started.
    I no longer watch and I haven’t missed it one bit.
    I got so sick of the stupid story lines and the too long
    storylines. They drag a storyline on for month after month
    after month. The writers are the worst ever. The baby
    switch has been done too much. How stupid is Sharon
    not to realize she really didn’t give birth.
    The characters are so boring. I hate that Victor never
    gets what is coming to him just once.
    Nick falls in love with every woman he meets, Dylan
    Is just plain sappy, sick of Lily and Cain and Noah
    the worst actor I have seen. Why did we need the
    storyline with Marisa, whose accent has disappeared
    Do not like Christine, boring and please get some new hair do’s. Lauren’s looks
    like she has a nest of spiders in it, and Christines is back with the hippies.
    When I was watching all I did was scream at the tv.
    I am much happier now that I no longer watch this
    awful show.

    Reply

    Carolyn replied

    Oh YEA!!! I do not like the last two Billy’s. Usually you find a close resemblance if not looks than characteristics. I like the old Billy. The new one looks too old.

    Reply

  93. Sarah says:

    Getting very tired of the great Dr Anderson coming to the rescue of all these people. It would be great if Sharon would find out the truth and take her down. The only problem is how. Mariah doesn’t trust her so maybe she can get through to Sharon. But no matter Sharon is going to be hurt again by suffering the loss of another child maybe she could get rid of the Doctor finally sick of her having the solution to everyone’s problems!

    Reply

  94. Delte says:

    I hate the story line . I hope it doesn’t go on for too long. It makes me want to stop watching. First of all most people know that their baby is theirs. Who has a baby in a mental hospital. When is a DNA test not done one a baby.I know this is television. But let’s be for real.

    Reply

  95. Shae says:

    I am so sick of Sharon, why’s she still on this show. Adam doesn’t want her anymore, he loves Chelsea. I don’t see why Adam and Sage can’t have their baby, they were an item so it’s logical that the baby would be Adam’s. You foolish writers, we all know that sully is really baby Christian so let Sage have her baby. Put the quack doctor’s business out there for all to know and let’s move on with this story line.

    Reply

  96. Martha Silva says:

    Can’t stand Dr. Anderson, how stupid if Dylan couldn’t figure out Sharon wasn’t pregnant. She wasn’t even showing. The only smart ones are sage nd Mariah. Adam is on to her too and will soon find put. Sharon is a nosy busy body and a trouble maker. Please when are they going to find out about Dr. Anderson??

    Reply

    Carolyn replied

    Isn’t that the truth!!!

    It would have been better if Dr. Anderson lived and it all came out while she was alive.

    YOU MESSED IT UP WHEN YOU LET PATTY KILL HER OFF!!!

    Reply

  97. Kris says:

    This story line is ridiculous. The sooner it’s ended the better. I’ve considered stopping watching Y&R. It’s beyond stupid. And Paul and his police force are the dumbest ever. you have allowed a baby to be taken from a woman that can no longer have children and suffered so much and given it to dumb cop Dylan and physco mother Sharon. you people are sick. Please end this.

    Reply

  98. Rita Johnson says:

    I think this is a dumb storyline and needs to come to a end.how come sage does not even know her on baby.no onnehas even asked for a birthday certificate. If this is a old girlfriend of nicks he should remember something.how long are they going to drag this out? Maybe Now Patti is back things will change. I’m tired.

    Reply

  99. Carolyn says:

    Come on Chuck Pratt. Give Sage and Nick the baby and Leave Adam out of it even if it is his and Sage. Adam and Chelsey need to stay together.

    Dylan and Sharon can have another baby. Sage needs this baby with Nick. NOT ADAM!!

    YOU ARE REALLY SCREWING UP A GREAT SHOW I’VE WATCHED SINCE 1973.

    STOP THE DUMB STUFF!!!!

    Reply

  100. Joyce says:

    I am so sick and tired of watching Nick and Sage suffer the loss of their baby while Sharon is walking around all blissful, give Nick and Sage their baby back it’s only fair

    Reply

  101. Wendy says:

    It’s much too unrealistic that this is Sharon’s baby – she has no memory of ever being pregnant

    Reply

    Rose replied

    Same story line as Ashley Adam and Sharon and Nick

    Reply

  102. Rose says:

    It’s time Sharon comes clean on her own and be a hero for once. When she figures it out let her be the one to do the right thing for once

    Reply

  103. Kelly says:

    Quit making Sharon the victim! Have her go after the Dr with a vengeance. Make Sharon a strong character with principles. A new “Superwoman.”

    Reply

  104. denise says:

    I am very upset I have been watching young & the restless for years since the fosters, I was so happy to see sage finding out about her baby then very disappointed to see you kill her off really why would you kill her off all that time she took to find out then to drag this thing on for Sharon to lye and for nick to lose a wife and a baby, if you wanted to write her off why didn’t you get someone else to play her, I am really upset because I was so happy to see that she found out only to get very disappointed to kill her off and have this storyline linger on. I am very upset with this outcome doesn’t make since.

    Reply

  105. dp says:

    Have you ever considered creating an ebook or guest authoring on other sites?

    I have a blog based upon on the same information you discuss and would love
    to have you share some stories/information. I know my subscribers
    would appreciate your work. If you’re even remotely interested, feel free to send me an email.

    Reply

Leave a comment