Jason tells Johnny the truth about what happened the night Claudia was killed after Johnny confronts him with the photo he received of Claudia’s empty grave. Johnny attacks Jason but eventually begins to calm down. Jason speculates as to why Franco would have sent Johnny the photo. Franco rents one of Sonny and Jason’s warehouses. Sam gets an unexpected visitor. Sonny plays along with Lisa when she assumes he’s the restaurant manager after she walks in looking to have dinner. Sonny deliberately pushes Olivia’s buttons when he notices she’s jealous over seeing him flirting with Lisa. Maxie helps Lulu get ready for her date with Dominic. Dominic whisks Lulu off into the night but won’t reveal where he’s taking her. Patrick and Robin are blissfully content as they celebrate their one year wedding anniversary. Jason gets the sense that something isn’t quite right when he finds no trace of Sam in her penthouse. Lucky tries to reach out to Michael after he’s pulled over for drunk driving but takes him home instead of arresting him. Sonny and Carly try to get through to Michael. A brooding Johnny tells Olivia he found out who killed Claudia but won’t share the information with her because of her connection to Dominic. Lulu groans with displeasure when she realizes Dominic is taking her to an opera for their date but surprises herself by enjoying the experience immensely. Dominic and Lulu come close to making love for the first time but the limo driver’s untimely interruption puts a stop to their plans.
Elizabeth surprises Lucky by recreating the night they spent together over ten years ago at Luke’s old club, but this time an empty Jake’s serves as the venue. Lucky is touched when Elizabeth presents him with his old guitar and begins to sing to her just like old times. Kristina and Molly set Alexis up on a date with Mac and she reluctantly agrees to go. Mac and Alexis’ car breaks down but they enjoy themselves dancing to the car’s radio. Kiefer leaves Kristina in tears after he storms off when she doesn’t want to make out with him. After jumping to the wrong conclusions about each other, Max and Diane kiss and make up. Maxie’s determined to make amends with Spinelli.